Clavem

Chargeback

A chargeback is a forced reversal of a card payment: the buyer asks their bank to take the money back, the bank pulls it from the seller's account, and the seller must prove the sale was legitimate to get it returned.

How it works

Stripe calls a chargeback a dispute. When a cardholder disputes a charge, Stripe tells you through the Dashboard, by email, through the API and by a charge.dispute.created event. It debits the disputed amount, plus a dispute fee, from your Stripe balance. Stripe explains the claim and walks you through sending evidence, but, in its words, it has no influence over the result. The cardholder’s bank decides.

The stages, according to Stripe’s documentation:

  1. Warning. An early fraud warning or an inquiry arrives before any money moves. Answering an inquiry with evidence, or refunding in full, resolves it without a dispute fee. Ignoring it can escalate it to a chargeback that is likely unwinnable.
  2. Dispute. The money and the fee leave your balance. You usually have 7 to 21 days to respond, depending on the network. Missing the deadline loses the dispute.
  3. Decision. The bank reviews your evidence, which can take up to 3 months. A lost dispute is normally final, though Stripe documents rare late wins.

Stripe groups reasons into categories such as fraudulent, product not received, product unacceptable, subscription canceled, duplicate and credit not processed. Each has its own evidence checklist.

What it costs

The fee for receiving a dispute is deducted when the dispute opens, and Stripe says it never returns it unless your contract says otherwise. Countering adds a second fee, which Stripe returns if you win. The amounts depend on your country; read them on Stripe’s pricing page.

An illustrative case, assuming a $49.00 license, a $1.77 processing fee and a $15.00 dispute fee (assumptions, not Stripe’s rates):

Outcome You end up with
You refund in full -$49.00 and the $1.77 fee is lost: -$50.77
Chargeback, you lose -$49.00, -$15.00 dispute fee, -$1.77: -$65.77
Chargeback, you win $49.00 back, but the $15.00 and $1.77 stay lost: -$16.77

Every route costs money. A refund is the cheapest way out of an unhappy sale, which is why a visible refund policy matters. Card networks also watch your dispute rate; Stripe lists monitoring programs.

Evidence for software

A disputed license is a digital sale with no shipment, so the useful evidence shows that the buyer got the product and used it: the order, the delivered key, the email the key went to, the download, and activation records with dates. The activation list is the strongest item. In Clavem, the management API’s license detail returns each device name with created_at and last_seen_at, and the license has a last_validated_at, so a buyer who “never received it” shows as three devices active last week. Stripe accepts one file per evidence type, so combine pages into one.

Chargeback versus refund

A refund is voluntary and final. A chargeback is involuntary and adversarial. After a chargeback, refunding the same payment on top of it risks paying twice, so check the dispute status in Stripe first.

How Clavem handles it

Clavem listens to six Stripe events and none is a dispute event. A full refund (charge.refunded) disables the order’s licenses, but a chargeback does not. The license stays active until you disable it, in the dashboard or with PATCH /v1/admin/licenses/:id and {"disabled": true}. Decide your own rule: many sellers disable on the dispute and re-enable if they win. See license revocation and Connecting Stripe.

A merchant of record takes dispute handling off you. Stripe’s documentation says its Managed Payments product handles disputes and submits evidence for you.

Questions

Is a chargeback the same as a refund?

No. You decide on a refund and it ends the matter. A chargeback is started by the buyer's bank without your agreement, takes the money and adds a fee, and you can only get the money back by winning with evidence.

How long do I have to respond to a chargeback on Stripe?

Stripe says you usually have 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network. If you miss the deadline you lose the dispute automatically.

Sources

  1. Stripe Docs, How disputes work (checked November 2026)
  2. Stripe Docs, Respond to disputes (checked November 2026)
  3. Stripe Docs, Dispute categories (checked November 2026)
  4. Stripe Docs, Managed Payments, how it works (checked November 2026)