Clavem

Freemium

Freemium is a pricing model where the basic version of a product is free for as long as the user likes, and paying customers get extra features, higher limits or support.

How it works

The free tier is the whole product for most users. The paid tier adds something they hit a limit on: more projects, an export format, sync, or support. There are three common limits.

  • Feature limits: PDF export is paid, PNG export is free.
  • Usage limits: 3 documents free, unlimited paid.
  • Service limits: community support free, email support paid.

Freemium has no end date, so the cost of a free user is permanent. Hosting, support and maintenance for people who never pay have to be covered by those who do.

Gating on a verified token

The app has two states, and the free tier is simply the state with no valid license. The code below uses isLicensed from the offline verification page and runs as written:

const FEATURES = {
  free: ['editor', 'png-export'],
  pro: ['editor', 'png-export', 'pdf-export', 'sync'],
};

function featuresFor(claims, productId) {
  return FEATURES[isLicensed(claims, productId) ? 'pro' : 'free'];
}

claims is null when there is no stored token or its signature failed, and then the user gets the free tier. The same happens when the license expires or refresh_by passes. The case to design for is the downgrade: a user who made a sync-enabled project on the paid tier must still open it. Decide what stays readable before you ship the gate.

A worked conversion calculation

An example, not a benchmark. The app has 10,000 free users, 2 percent buy at $29, and each buyer pays once. Revenue is 10,000 x 0.02 x $29 = $5,800. Each half point of conversion is worth 10,000 x 0.005 x $29 = $1,450. Set the hosting, support time and maintenance for 9,800 non-paying users against that figure. Freemium pays when free users bring in buyers who would not have found the product otherwise.

Freemium versus a free trial

A trial license limits time. Freemium limits scope. Trials suit products where the whole experience is the sale. Freemium suits products where free users make the product better known, such as a design tool people share files from. The tradeoffs are covered in free trial vs freemium. A related model, open core, keeps the free part open source.

How Clavem handles it

Clavem does not need to know about your free tier. Free users never enter a key, so they hold no license and do not count toward your plan, which counts only licenses that can still be used. The paid state starts when a customer activates a key.

If you sell several paid tiers, give each its own Clavem product. Each product has its own signing key, so the signed pid tells your app which tier a token belongs to. See entitlement.

Questions

What is the difference between freemium and a free trial?

A free trial gives you everything for a limited time. Freemium gives you a smaller product with no time limit. The first creates a deadline, the second creates a ceiling.

What should the app do when a paid license lapses?

Fall back to the free tier. Keep the customer's data readable and exportable, and turn off only the paid features.