What the model does
The same number of new customers arrives every month in both models. Under one-time pricing each one pays the price once. Every cohort of buyers is then offered an upgrade at the interval you set, and the share you choose buys it. Under subscription pricing each active subscriber pays every month, and a fixed share of active subscribers cancels before the next month. The chart adds each month's revenue to a running total for each model.
How to read the result
Early on the one-time line is usually higher, because a new buyer pays the whole price on day one. The subscription line starts lower and climbs as subscribers accumulate. Where the lines cross, subscriptions have brought in more in total. If they do not cross within your horizon, extend the months or look at the monthly figures: the subscription line may still be rising faster. The sentences above the chart work out what one customer is worth in each model, which is the number to compare when you are unsure about volumes.
Assumptions to keep in mind
- Revenue only: no payment fees, tax, refunds, support or server costs. See the fee calculator for fees.
- New customers stay flat. Real sales rise and fall, and a launch spike changes the picture.
- Churn is the same every month. In practice, many subscribers leave early.
- No discounts, annual plans, trials or price changes, and no value placed on getting money sooner.
Clavem issues a perpetual license for a one-time Stripe payment and a license that follows the paid period of a Stripe subscription, so either model works. How the license follows a subscription is described inConnecting Stripe.
Questions
Which is better, one-time or subscription?
Neither wins everywhere. A one-time price brings cash early and suits software that is finished once, with paid upgrades for new versions. A subscription brings more in total only if customers stay long enough, and it fits software with running costs such as servers or data. The chart shows where the lines cross for your numbers.
What churn rate should I use?
Use your own data if you have any. Without it, try several values and watch how much the result moves. Churn matters more than almost any other input, because it decides how long an average subscriber pays.
Does it include payment fees and tax?
No. Every figure is revenue before payment fees, tax, refunds and costs. Use the Stripe fee calculator to see what fees take from each option.
How do I model a perpetual license with a year of updates?
Set the one-time price to the license price, the upgrade price to the renewal price and "a paid upgrade every" to 12 months, then set the take-up to the share of customers who renew.
More on choosing a price is in the Clavem pricing example and theStripe fee calculator. More tools are listed under free tools.