Clavem

Merchant of record vs Stripe: what changes for software sellers

A merchant of record (MoR) is the company that legally sells to your customer, so it collects and files the sales tax, VAT and GST, and handles disputes. You pay for that with a higher fee per sale. Stripe alone is cheaper but leaves tax to you.

The short answer

With plain Stripe you are the seller. You collect any sales tax or VAT that applies to your buyers, register where the law requires it, file the returns, and answer disputes. With a merchant of record you are the supplier to the MoR, and the MoR is the seller to your customer: it charges and files the tax, takes the chargebacks and handles buyer support for the transaction. The price is a higher percentage on every sale.

Neither is better in general. The right choice depends on your monthly sales, where your buyers live and how much of the tax work you are willing to do. This article puts numbers on the fee difference and lists what else changes. It is general information, not tax or legal advice.

What a merchant of record does

Stripe’s Managed Payments documentation gives a concrete list, which is a fair description of the role in general:

  • calculates, collects, files and remits sales tax, VAT and GST in more than 80 countries, based on product classification and customer location
  • shows the customer a receipt and invoice sent by the MoR, not by you
  • manages fraud screening and disputes, including submitting evidence on your behalf
  • provides transaction-level customer support, while you keep product-level support

In countries it does not cover, Stripe says you remain responsible for tax compliance. Read the coverage list of any MoR you consider, because the promise is only as wide as its country list.

What the fees look like

All figures below are published rates as of November 2026. Merchants of record quote one rate that includes payment processing. Stripe Managed Payments is quoted as an addition to Stripe’s own processing fee.

Option Published rate Fee on a $49 sale $2,000 a month $10,000 a month $50,000 a month Tax handled for you
Stripe alone 2.9% + $0.30 (assumed) $1.72 $70 $351 $1,756 No
Stripe Managed Payments Standard Stripe fee + 3.5% $3.44 $140 $701 $3,506 Yes, 80+ countries
Managed Payments, Lemon Squeezy promo Standard Stripe fee + 1.5% to 1 Dec 2027 $2.46 $100 $501 $2,506 Yes, 80+ countries
Paddle 5% + $0.50 per Checkout transaction $2.95 $120 $602 $3,010 Yes
Polar, Starter 5% + $0.50 $2.95 $120 $602 $3,010 Yes
Polar, Pro $20 a month, then 3.8% + $0.40 $2.26 $112 $482 $2,328 Yes
Creem 3.9% + $0.40 $2.31 $94 $472 $2,358 Yes
Dodo Payments 4% + $0.40 $2.36 $96 $482 $2,408 Yes

How the table was built, so you can redo it with your own numbers:

  • Every sale is $49, so $2,000 is about 41 orders, $10,000 about 204 and $50,000 about 1,020. Fee = percentage times sales plus fixed fee times orders, plus any monthly fee.
  • The Stripe base rate is 2.9% plus $0.30 on every order. That is the usual US domestic card rate and is an assumption: Stripe’s rates depend on your account’s country. The Swiss page, for example, shows 2.9% plus CHF 0.30 for Swiss cards, 3.25% plus CHF 0.30 for international cards and an extra 2% when currency conversion is needed. Several MoRs add similar surcharges for non-US cards (Polar and Dodo list +1.5%), so the gaps between rows stay roughly the same.
  • Fees are computed on the $49 price before tax. Polar’s own worked example charges its fee on the tax-inclusive total, so on EU sales every row is a little higher than shown.
  • The Lemon Squeezy promotional rate applies to Lemon Squeezy merchants who migrate. It starts when they install the migration toolkit, as early as 2 December 2026.
  • Lemon Squeezy’s own rate was 5% plus $0.50, but it stops processing on 31 March 2027 and is not open to new sign-ups.

Three things stand out. At the standard rate, Managed Payments costs more than Paddle or Polar Starter on a $49 sale (7.0% against 6.0%), because its 3.5% is added to Stripe’s own fee. With the promotional rate it costs less (5.0%). And Polar’s tiers trade a monthly fee for a lower rate: Pro is already a little cheaper than Starter at $2,000 a month, while Growth ($100 a month plus 3.6% + $0.35) costs more than Pro until sales pass roughly $26,000 a month on these assumptions.

The premium over Stripe alone is what you are really buying tax handling with. For Managed Payments at the standard rate that is 3.5% of sales: $70 a month at $2,000, $350 at $10,000 and $1,750 at $50,000.

What the premium has to beat

Doing tax yourself is not free, so compare the premium with your own cost:

  • Stripe Tax. Stripe’s tax pricing page lists a per-transaction fee on its no-code integration where you are registered to collect (0.5% on the Swiss page) and a Tax Complete tier starting at CHF 80 a month with registrations, calculations and filings included.
  • Your time or an accountant’s. Registration, returns and threshold monitoring. How much depends on how many jurisdictions you sell into, which is hard to predict for software sold worldwide.
  • Risk. If tax was owed and you did not collect it, dealing with that is your job as the seller. With a merchant of record, the collection duty sits with the MoR in the countries it covers.

At $2,000 a month the premium is $70 at the standard Managed Payments rate, small in absolute terms, so the question is mostly whether you want the tax work at all. At $50,000 the premium is $1,750 a month, and a subscription tax service may cost less depending on how many registrations you need, as long as you are comfortable being the seller of record. The crossover is yours to calculate: monthly premium against the sum of everything above.

What else changes in practice

The fee is not the only difference. This table uses Stripe Managed Payments because its documentation is public and detailed. Other MoRs vary, so check theirs.

Topic Stripe alone Merchant of record (Managed Payments)
Who the buyer sees as seller You Link. Statements show LINK.COM followed by your descriptor
Receipts and emails Yours, from your settings Sent from Link. Your receipt settings do not apply
Disputes You respond and pay Stripe’s dispute fee Stripe handles them and submits evidence for you
Checkout choice Payment Links, Checkout, Elements, Payment Intents Checkout and Payment Links only. Elements and custom flows are unsupported
Checkout domain Your own custom domain is possible Custom domains are not supported on Managed Payments checkouts
Products allowed Anything Stripe permits Digital products: software, games, media, courses. No physical goods, professional services or live events
Account types Any, including Connect platforms Direct integrations only, in supported business locations, after an eligibility review
Subscription changes by buyer Your customer portal Buyers manage orders on the Link website
License keys and downloads Not included Not included for Managed Payments. Some other MoRs include them

The last row matters for software. Lemon Squeezy’s migration documentation says Managed Payments does not deliver files, license keys or download links. Polar and Dodo Payments list license keys as features. If you choose a MoR without keys, you still need a key layer.

When a merchant of record wins

  • You sell to buyers in many countries and have no appetite for VAT registrations.
  • Monthly sales are low enough that the premium is small in absolute terms.
  • You want disputes and buyer payment support taken off your desk.
  • You are a single founder and your time is the scarce resource.

When Stripe alone wins

  • Most buyers are in one or two countries, so registrations stay few.
  • Sales are high enough that a flat tax service costs far less than a percentage of every sale.
  • You need a custom checkout, Connect, a custom domain or a product that a MoR does not accept.
  • You want the customer relationship and receipts under your own name.

The choice is not permanent. Moving from one to the other later is easier if your license keys do not depend on the payment platform.

Doing this with Clavem

Clavem is not a merchant of record, takes no payments and does not handle tax. It works on top of your own Stripe account and issues keys when a Checkout Session is paid, so the choice above is independent of it. With plain Stripe it runs as described in the Stripe guide. With Managed Payments, purchases are made through Stripe Checkout, so they should produce the objects Clavem listens for, but treat that as something to test with one purchase rather than assume.

If you later move between the two, your keys and your app’s code do not change. Clavem’s flat price starts at $29 a month and its pricing page has the limits.

Questions

Is Stripe a merchant of record?

Not by default. With a standard Stripe account you are the seller. Stripe Managed Payments is a separate product in which Stripe acts as merchant of record for eligible digital products, for an extra 3.5% per successful transaction on top of standard Stripe fees.

Does a merchant of record make me exempt from tax?

It moves the collection and filing of sales tax, VAT and GST to the merchant of record in the countries it covers. Your own income tax and company obligations stay with you. Check the details with an accountant.

Which is cheaper for software, Stripe or a merchant of record?

Stripe alone has the lower per-sale fee. A merchant of record can still cost less overall if doing tax yourself costs more than the difference, which is more likely at low volumes and with many countries of buyers.

Sources

  1. Stripe docs, how Managed Payments works (as of November 2026)
  2. Stripe docs, Managed Payments eligibility (as of November 2026)
  3. Stripe docs, Managed Payments overview and comparison (as of November 2026)
  4. Stripe, Managed Payments pricing (as of November 2026)
  5. Stripe pricing, Switzerland page (as of November 2026)
  6. Stripe Tax pricing (as of November 2026)
  7. Lemon Squeezy migration documentation (as of November 2026)
  8. Lemon Squeezy pricing (as of November 2026)
  9. Paddle pricing (as of November 2026)
  10. Polar, merchant of record fees (as of November 2026)
  11. Creem pricing (as of November 2026)
  12. Dodo Payments pricing (as of November 2026)