One sale, every option
All figures below come from each company’s own pricing page as of November 2026 and apply to a standard account. Your rate can differ by country, volume and contract. The example is a $49 one-time purchase with a domestic card, with no refund or dispute.
| Option | Published fee | Fee on $49 | Net | Share of price | Sales tax and VAT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe alone | 2.9% + $0.30 | $1.72 | $47.28 | 3.5% | You |
| Stripe with Managed Payments | Stripe fees + 3.5% | $3.44 | $45.56 | 7.0% | Stripe, as merchant of record |
| Same, with the 1.5% migration promotion | Stripe fees + 1.5% | $2.46 | $46.54 | 5.0% | Stripe |
| Paddle | 5% + $0.50 | $2.95 | $46.05 | 6.0% | Paddle, as merchant of record |
| Polar, Starter plan | 5% + $0.50 | $2.95 | $46.05 | 6.0% | Polar, as merchant of record |
| Creem | 3.9% + $0.40 | $2.31 | $46.69 | 4.7% | Creem includes tax |
| Dodo Payments, US cards | 4% + $0.40 | $2.36 | $46.64 | 4.8% | Dodo includes tax |
| Gumroad, direct sales | 10% + $0.50 | $5.40 | $43.60 | 11.0% | Gumroad, as merchant of record |
| Lemon Squeezy | 5% + $0.50 | $2.95 | $46.05 | 6.0% | Lemon Squeezy, closing 31 March 2027 |
The Stripe Managed Payments row uses Stripe’s published 2.9% plus $0.30 card rate and adds 3.5%. The pricing page says the 3.5% is charged per successful Managed Payments transaction “in addition to Payments fees”. The 2.9% plus 30 cents figure is Stripe’s Swiss domestic card rate, shown in Swiss francs on the page, and I use it in dollars as an assumption for the comparison.
Two rows deserve a second look. Stripe’s own merchant-of-record product, at full price, costs more per sale than Paddle or Polar. Stripe’s reason to buy it is that you stay on Stripe, not that it is the cheapest merchant of record. And the migration promotion, 1.5% in place of 3.5% through 1 December 2027 for Lemon Squeezy merchants, makes it cheaper than the others for a while.
What each row leaves out
The tax column is the point of the table. The Stripe-alone fee is lowest because it buys payment processing and nothing else. Registering for VAT or sales tax, charging the right rate and filing returns remain your job unless you add Stripe Tax or a merchant of record. A merchant of record is the seller of record, so it takes on those duties. See merchant of record versus Stripe.
Keys and downloads are separate. Stripe, with or without Managed Payments, does not generate license keys or host downloads. Lemon Squeezy’s migration guide says Managed Payments “doesn’t deliver files, license keys, or download links”. On the Stripe rows you add a licensing service, which is why the next table includes Clavem’s price. Check each other platform’s page for whether keys are included before you compare.
Monthly cost at three volumes
Assume a $49 price and domestic cards. For the Stripe rows, add Clavem’s flat price, which depends on the active licenses you hold: 12 months at 20 sales a month is 240 licenses (Indie, $29), at 100 a month it is 1,200 (Studio, $79) and at 500 a month it is 6,000 (Studio, $79).
| Monthly sales | 20 ($980) | 100 ($4,900) | 500 ($24,500) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe + Clavem (tax is yours) | $63.42 | $251.10 | $939.50 |
| Stripe + Managed Payments + Clavem | $97.72 | $422.60 | $1,797.00 |
| Same, with the 1.5% promotion | $78.12 | $324.60 | $1,307.00 |
| Paddle or Polar Starter | $59.00 | $295.00 | $1,475.00 |
| Creem | $46.22 | $231.10 | $1,155.50 |
| Dodo Payments, US cards | $47.20 | $236.00 | $1,180.00 |
| Gumroad, direct | $108.00 | $540.00 | $2,700.00 |
The figures are my arithmetic from the published rates, not quotes. Three readings follow.
- At low volume, a percentage plan wins. Creem is cheaper than Stripe plus Clavem until about 49 sales a month at $49, and Dodo until about 45. Paddle until about 24. The flat monthly price has to be earned back by the lower per-sale fee.
- At higher volume, the flat price wins. At 500 sales a month, Stripe plus Clavem costs $939.50, against $1,155.50 for Creem and $1,475.00 for Paddle, with the tax work left with you.
- At full price, Managed Payments plus a license service costs more than every other row at every volume, except Gumroad’s direct rate. Choose it for what it does, which is tax and Stripe as the seller, not for the price.
Where the fixed fee bites
On a cheap product the per-sale part of the fee dominates. At $9, Stripe’s fee is $0.56 (6.2%), Creem’s is $0.75 (8.3%), Stripe with Managed Payments is $0.88 (9.7%) and Paddle’s is $0.95 (10.6%). If you sell a low-priced app, price in tiers or bundles, or sell a year of updates rather than a $9 license.
What the headline rate does not include
The published rate is where the real cost starts, not where it ends.
- International cards. Stripe’s Swiss page lists 3.25% plus CHF 0.30 for international cards, plus 2% if currency conversion is required. Polar and Dodo each list an extra 1.5% for international cards.
- Subscriptions. Stripe Billing adds 0.7% of Billing volume on its pay-as-you-go plan, and Dodo lists an extra 0.5% for subscriptions.
- Disputes. Polar lists a $15 fee per dispute, whatever the outcome. Stripe charges a dispute fee as well. Managed Payments hands disputes to Stripe but a received dispute still carries a fee.
- Refunds. Stripe says the payment processing and currency conversion fees from the original transaction are not returned when you refund.
- Payouts. Platforms may pass on payout provider fees. Polar says it adds none beyond what Stripe charges.
Add one of these to the calculation if it applies to you. A seller whose buyers are mostly outside their own country pays more than the table shows on the Stripe rows and on Polar and Dodo.
Doing this with Clavem
Clavem is the licensing layer for the Stripe rows. It charges $0 for up to 50 active licenses, $29 for 1,000, $79 for 10,000 and $199 for 50,000 a month, with no share of sales, and it never touches the payment. It does not collect or file tax. The Stripe fee calculator lets you test your own price and volume, and how to price a desktop app covers choosing the price itself.
Questions
What does Stripe charge for card payments?
Stripe's standard pricing page for Switzerland lists 2.9% plus CHF 0.30 for domestic cards and 3.25% plus CHF 0.30 for international cards, with a further 2% when currency conversion is needed. Rates differ by country, so check the pricing page for your own account.
How much does Stripe Managed Payments cost?
Stripe lists 3.5% per successful Managed Payments transaction in addition to its payments fees. Lemon Squeezy's migration guide says merchants who migrate get a promotional 1.5% through 1 December 2027.
Is a merchant of record worth the higher fee?
If you do not want to register for sales tax and VAT in the places you sell, collect it and file returns, yes. If your sales are small and in a few places, you may prefer to handle tax yourself and pay less per sale. This is a decision for you and your accountant.
Sources
- Stripe pricing, standard card rates, Billing and Managed Payments (as of November 2026)
- Paddle pricing (as of November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy pricing (as of November 2026)
- Gumroad pricing (as of November 2026)
- Polar pricing (as of November 2026)
- Creem pricing (as of November 2026)
- Dodo Payments pricing (as of November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy migration guide, Managed Payments promotional price (as of November 2026)