Clavem

Lifetime deals for software: pros, cons and the break-even math

A lifetime deal is worth running when its price equals at least as many months of subscription as a subscriber is expected to stay, which is one divided by your monthly churn. At 5% churn that is 20 months, so a $9 a month product needs a lifetime price near $180, and the deal turns bad when support and hosting costs run for years against one payment.

Why sellers run lifetime deals

A lifetime deal sells the app once for a larger price and never bills again. Sellers use them for three reasons: cash arrives immediately, buyers avoid a subscription they dislike, and a launch needs a reason to buy today.

The cash effect is real. If 40 people buy a $149 lifetime license in a month, you collect $5,960. The same 40 people on a $9 subscription pay $360 that month, and it takes 16.6 months of subscription to match the lifetime price. That is useful when you are funding the next version. It is a liability if you are counting on the income to fund the support of the last one.

The pricing rule: months of subscription

The question is how many months of subscription the lifetime price should buy. The answer comes from how long subscribers stay. If a share c of subscribers cancels each month, the expected stay is 1 / c months. A lifetime price below that many months of subscription is a discount against the average subscriber; above it, the buyer pays more than an average subscriber would.

All numbers below use an assumed churn of 5% a month. That is a placeholder, not data. Replace it with the rate you measure.

Lifetime price Subscription price Break-even months Expected subscription revenue, 36 months Expected subscription revenue, total
$79 $6 a month 13.2 $101 $120
$149 $9 a month 16.6 $152 $180
$199 $12 a month 16.6 $202 $240
$299 $15 a month 19.9 $253 $300

At 5% churn the expected total is 20 times the monthly price. A $149 lifetime price against a $9 plan is $31 below the $180 an average subscriber pays in total, a discount of about 17%, and anyone who would have stayed longer than 17 months saves money. At 8% churn the expected stay is 12.5 months, so the same plan would justify a lifetime price near $112. A lifetime price of 17 to 20 times the monthly price is a reasonable first test at 5% churn. Treat it as a rule of thumb to test, not as a finding.

Stripe’s fee barely changes the picture for a lifetime sale. At the US rate of 2.9% plus 30 cents, a $149 sale costs $4.62 and nets $144.38. Rates depend on your country.

This script reproduces the table and the plan costs further down. It needs Node and no packages.

// node lifetime.mjs
const churn = 0.05; // assumption: 5% of subscribers cancel each month
const deals = [[79, 6], [149, 9], [199, 12], [299, 15]]; // [lifetime price, monthly price]

for (const [lifetime, monthly] of deals) {
  const breakEven = lifetime / monthly;
  const expected36 = (monthly * (1 - (1 - churn) ** 36)) / churn;
  const expectedAll = monthly / churn;
  console.log(`$${lifetime} vs $${monthly}/mo: break-even ${breakEven.toFixed(1)} months, ` +
    `${expected36.toFixed(0)} in 36 months, ${expectedAll.toFixed(0)} in total`);
}

// Clavem plans by active licenses: Free 50, Indie 1,000 ($29), Studio 10,000 ($79), Scale 50,000 ($199)
const plans = [['Free', 50, 0], ['Indie', 1000, 29], ['Studio', 10000, 79], ['Scale', 50000, 199]];
const planFor = (n) => plans.find(([, limit]) => n <= limit);

for (const salesPerMonth of [10, 40, 150]) {
  let total = 0;
  for (let month = 1; month <= 60; month++) total += planFor(salesPerMonth * month)[2];
  console.log(`${salesPerMonth} sales a month: $${total} of plan fees over 60 months, ` +
    `$${(total / (salesPerMonth * 60)).toFixed(2)} per license sold`);
}

What a lifetime customer costs after the sale

Support

Every lifetime customer can write to you for as long as the product exists. Assume each one costs $0.50 a month in your time and $1.50 for a heavier product. A $149 sale nets $144.38, which covers 289 months of support at $0.50 and 96 months at $1.50. The second figure is 8 years. If you expect to support the product for longer than that, the sale no longer pays for its own support, and the buyer brings no further income to cover it.

Hosting

If the app calls your servers or a paid API, each lifetime customer is a permanent monthly cost against one payment. Divide the net price by your monthly cost per active user to get the months the deal can run. A product with real per-user cost should not sell lifetime licenses.

The license platform

On Clavem, a license that is neither revoked nor expired counts toward the plan. Lifetime licenses never expire, so they accumulate. Plans by active licenses: Free 50, Indie 1,000 at $29 a month, Studio 10,000 at $79, Scale 50,000 at $199.

Lifetime sales per month Licenses after 12 / 36 / 60 months Plan at 12 / 36 / 60 months Plan fees over 60 months Per license sold
10 120 / 360 / 600 Indie / Indie / Indie $1,595 $2.66
40 480 / 1,440 / 2,400 Indie / Studio / Studio $3,461 $1.44
150 1,800 / 5,400 / 9,000 Studio / Studio / Studio $4,440 $0.49

The platform is a small part of the price of a lifetime license. The point is that the cost never ends. It moves up a tier as the catalogue grows, so build it into the model. Revoking old licenses, such as refunded ones, removes them from the count.

Pros and cons

In favour Against
Cash up front, useful to fund development No recurring revenue, so you need new buyers every month
Buyers avoid subscription fatigue Support and hosting costs outlast the payment
Simple to explain and to license: a key that never expires “Lifetime” is vague unless your terms define it
Fewer failed payments and cancellations to handle Hard to raise the price for existing buyers later
Useful as a launch offer Cheap keys are easy to share if the device limit is loose

Say what lifetime means

A buyer reads “lifetime” as their own lifetime. You almost certainly mean something smaller. Pick a definition, write it on the pricing page, and put it in your terms.

Wording Meaning Risk
Life of the buyer Works until they stop using it Open-ended, hard to fund
Life of the product Works while you sell and support it Needs a clear end-of-life promise
Life of the major version All updates within version 3.x Clear, and fits upgrade pricing
A fixed number of years Works for N years Not really a lifetime deal; call it by its name

The usual choice is life of the major version, with new majors sold as upgrades. This is general information, not legal advice; have your terms reviewed, and see writing an EULA.

Edge cases

  • You close the business. A lifetime promise should survive you. With signed license tokens an app can keep verifying a license offline after the server is gone, and your app can choose to keep trusting an expired freshness window. Decide that rule before you sell lifetime licenses, and tell buyers.
  • Resale and transfer. Decide whether a lifetime license can move to another person or computer. Moving between your buyer’s own computers is a device-limit question, covered in license transfers between computers.
  • Cheap keys leak. A discounted lifetime key is more tempting to share. Keep the device limit tight on deep discounts.
  • Refunds. A refund in the first weeks is normal. In Clavem a full refund in Stripe disables the licenses from that order and removes them from the plan count; a partial refund changes nothing.

Doing this with Clavem

A perpetual license is the default shape: a product with perpetual validity issues a key that never expires, and a one-time Stripe price mapped to it issues the key when the Checkout Session completes. A lifetime price and a monthly price of one Stripe product can map to different Clavem products. Clavem does not decide what lifetime means; your terms do. Its plans are flat, with no cut of sales, so the table above is the whole platform cost. See the pricing page for the current limits.

Questions

How much should a lifetime license cost compared with a subscription?

A fair starting point is the monthly price multiplied by the number of months a subscriber is expected to stay, which is one divided by monthly churn. At 5% monthly churn that is 20 months. Measure your own churn before using the number.

What does lifetime mean in a license?

Whatever your terms say. Tie it to something you control, such as the life of the product or a major version, rather than the life of the buyer, and say what happens if you stop selling or supporting the product.

Does a lifetime license count toward my Clavem plan?

Yes, for as long as it is neither revoked nor expired. A perpetual license never expires, so lifetime sales accumulate against the plan limit until you revoke them.

Sources

  1. Stripe pricing page, card rates are set per country (as of November 2026)