Clavem

Clavem vs Dodo Payments: a merchant of record with keys against a flat-priced license layer

Dodo Payments is a merchant of record that charges 4% plus 40 cents, handles tax and issues license keys with activation limits. Clavem keeps your own Stripe account and charges a flat monthly plan for keys, device seats and downloads, without handling tax. Dodo suits sellers who want one vendor and global payment methods; Clavem suits sellers who want Stripe and a fixed price.

Side by side

Dodo Payments facts are as of November 2026, from its pricing page and documentation.

Clavem Dodo Payments (as of November 2026)
Price Free for 50 active licenses; $29, $79 or $199 a month No fixed cost on the standard plan; per transaction
Fees on 100 sales of $49 $29 plan, plus Stripe’s fee: about $201 4% plus 40 cents: $236
Merchant of record No Yes, with tax calculation, filing and reporting
License keys Created when Stripe confirms a payment A license key entitlement attached to a product
Device limits Per license; buyer device page Activation limit per key, or unlimited
Offline checks Signed sgt1 token Not published
Downloads Releases, order page, update endpoint Digital product delivery, listed as included
API License API plus management API Public activate, validate and deactivate endpoints; keys can be imported by API
Migration path Dodo importer, plus file import Create keys by API with POST /license_keys; no notification sent to customers

Fees on 100 sales of $49

Dodo’s standard plan is 4% plus 40 cents. On $4,900 that is $196 plus $40, $236. A subscription payment adds 0.5%, which makes it $260.50. International cards add 1.5%, and PayPal adds 3%. With Clavem and Stripe’s standard US card rate of 2.9% plus 30 cents (as of November 2026), the cost is $29 plus $172.10, $201.10. Dodo’s price covers the merchant-of-record work; Clavem’s does not.

Dodo’s pricing page lists “Other providers charge 5% plus 50c” next to its own rate. That is Dodo’s own comparison, and it is not used here.

How Dodo’s keys behave

Dodo creates keys through entitlements. You define a license key entitlement once, with an activation limit, a license length and an optional activation message, then attach it to products. One key is generated per unit bought, or per seat on a subscription.

The lifecycle follows the subscription, according to Dodo’s table:

  • A renewal changes nothing.
  • A past-due subscription keeps its keys active through the grace period.
  • A subscription put on hold or paused disables the keys, and they return when it resumes.
  • A cancelled or expired subscription disables them permanently.

Clavem’s subscription rule is simpler: a license expires at the end of the paid period plus three days of grace, comes back when a late payment settles, and a refund in Stripe disables it. Neither is better; they are different policies, so check which one matches your terms.

Dodo’s activate, validate and deactivate endpoints are public, which means your app can call them without an API key. Clavem’s License API works the same way: the license key is the credential.

Dodo also offers manual fulfilment, where you supply your own keys. That helps if your own license server already generates keys and you only want Dodo to hold them.

When Dodo Payments is the better choice

  • You want a merchant of record covering tax, fraud and disputes, in one place with checkout, keys and delivery.
  • Your customers pay with local methods. Dodo lists UPI and local cards in India, ACH, SEPA, and buy-now-pay-later options.
  • You want a storefront, affiliates and usage-based billing alongside licensing.
  • You have no Stripe account, or do not want to run one.
  • Your sales are small enough that a percentage costs less than a monthly plan.

When Clavem is the better choice

  • You want to stay on your own Stripe account and keep customers, payouts and invoices there.
  • Sales are high enough that a flat price costs less than a percentage.
  • You want a signed token that your app verifies offline.
  • You want the Lemon Squeezy License API shape, which Dodo’s documentation does not describe.

Moving between the two

Clavem imports from Dodo directly. In the dashboard open Import, choose Dodo Payments, pick live or test mode and paste an API key with read access to license keys, customers and products. Map each Dodo product to a Clavem product. Keys, buyers, status, activation limits, expiry dates and instances come over page by page; a stopped run resumes where it ended. A Dodo key with no limit becomes an unlimited Clavem key. The API key is used for that run only and is not stored. See importing licenses and moving from Dodo Payments.

Your app’s calls change, because Dodo’s endpoints and request fields differ from Clavem’s. Dodo documents the other direction too: you can bring keys from another system into Dodo with its Create License Key API, which keeps customers on the same key strings.

If you go the other way, from Clavem to Dodo

Export your keys from Clavem as CSV. To import them into Dodo, its documentation lists three required fields per key: the key itself, a customer id and a product id. Omit the activation limit for an unlimited key and omit the expiry for a key that never expires. Importing a key string that already exists returns a 409 error. Keys created or changed through the API do not send an email, so you have to tell customers yourself. The documented import fields cover the key, customer, product, limit and expiry, and the import request has no subscription field, so an imported subscription key does not follow the subscription’s status afterwards. Activated devices are not among the documented fields, so plan for customers to activate again on first launch of the updated app. Clavem has the same property in the opposite direction: an imported license has no Stripe subscription behind it, so Stripe events never change it.

Dodo’s documentation also describes a dodo-migrate command-line tool that imports products, customers, discounts and license keys in bulk from Polar.sh or Lemon Squeezy. For a Lemon Squeezy seller choosing between the two, that is one of the points in Dodo’s favour.

Questions

How much does Dodo Payments charge?

As of November 2026 its standard rate is 4% plus 40 cents per transaction, with extras such as 1.5% for international payments, 3% for PayPal and buy-now-pay-later methods, and 0.5% on subscriptions. Its pricing page lists license keys and digital product delivery as included.

Can Clavem import license keys from Dodo Payments?

Yes. Clavem has a Dodo Payments importer that brings over keys, buyers, status, activation limits, expiry dates and license key instances. Instances keep their Dodo ids, so an app that stored the instance id can send it to Clavem as instance_id.

Do Dodo license keys work offline?

Dodo's license key documentation describes activate, validate and deactivate calls to its servers. It does not describe signed offline tokens, so offline behaviour is not published.

Sources

  1. Dodo Payments pricing page (checked November 2026)
  2. Dodo Payments documentation, license keys (checked November 2026)
  3. Stripe pricing page, card rate (checked November 2026)