Clavem

Dodo Payments alternatives: what the surcharges add up to, and who else sells keys

Dodo Payments is a merchant of record at 4% plus 40 cents with license keys included, and its price table adds percentages for international cards, subscriptions and PayPal, plus fees for refunds and disputes. The alternatives are compared on one cheap subscription, where the fixed fee and the surcharges matter most.

Why people look for an alternative

Dodo Payments is a merchant of record: it resells your digital product to the buyer, handles tax, chargebacks and payment processing, and pays you the rest. License keys are an entitlement on a product with an activation limit, expiry and an activation message, and by default one key is issued per unit or subscription seat. The reasons sellers compare it are in its published price list and its eligibility rules.

As of November 2026 the pricing page lists:

Item Charge
Card and wallet payments, US 4% + 40 cents
International payments (cards and local methods outside the US) +1.5%
Subscriptions, add-ons and usage-based billing +0.5%
PayPal +3%
Klarna, Afterpay, Clearpay +3%
India, local cards and UPI 4% + 15 cents, plus international fees
ACH and SEPA direct debit 1.5%, capped at $15 or 15 euros, replacing the card fee
Refund $1
Dispute $30

Two other facts come from its documentation. Eligibility depends on the country that issued the identity documents you verify with, and for a company on every director’s and beneficial owner’s documents. And the merchant acceptance policy restricts or prohibits some categories, such as physical goods and age-restricted products. Neither is unusual for a merchant of record, but both are reasons to check before you commit.

What to check before you switch

  1. Your buyers’ mix. Count how many of your sales are international, recurring, or paid with PayPal. Each adds to the base rate.
  2. Your price. A fixed 40 cents weighs more on a $5 plan than on a $99 license. The worked example below uses a cheap subscription for that reason.
  3. Refunds and disputes. Ask each provider what it charges per refund and per dispute. Dodo lists $1 and $30.
  4. Eligibility. Ask the next provider what it checks: country of the account holder, of the company, or of the bank.
  5. Keys and activations. Dodo keys have activation limits and instance ids. A new service needs a way to import keys with those ids so installed apps keep working. Clavem’s Dodo importer keeps the ids.
  6. Subscribers. A merchant of record holds saved cards. Ask Dodo whether you can request an export, and plan for subscribers who have to check out again.

A cheap subscription, compared

A $12 monthly subscription paid with a card from outside the United States. Headline rates on the price, as of November 2026, before tax effects:

Provider Rate used Fee per renewal Share of the price
Dodo Payments 4% + 1.5% + 0.5% + 40 cents $1.12 9.3%
Polar Early Member 4% + 1.5% + 0.5% + 40 cents $1.12 9.3%
Polar Starter 5% + 1.5% + 50 cents $1.28 10.7%
Paddle 5% + 50 cents $1.10 9.2%
Creem 3.9% + 40 cents $0.87 7.2%

Polar applies its percentage to the total including VAT, so its rows are a little higher in a VAT country. The point is the shape: on a $12 plan the fixed fee is a third of the cost, and each percentage surcharge matters less than the 40 or 50 cents.

The alternatives

Creem

A merchant of record at 3.9% plus 40 cents, no monthly fee, no setup fee and no international card surcharge, with license keys and file delivery included. Its checkout takes cards, Apple Pay and Google Pay, not PayPal. Its license docs describe activate, validate and deactivate endpoints, a status of inactive, active, expired or disabled, and an activation limit per key.

Polar

An open-source merchant of record with a license key benefit that supports activation limits, expiry and usage quotas. Starter is 5% plus 50 cents. Organizations created before 27 May 2026 stay on an Early Member rate of 4% plus 40 cents with a 0.5% subscription fee. Paid plans at $20, $100 and $400 a month lower the rate.

Paddle

A merchant of record at 5% plus 50 cents with no monthly fee and no extra charge for additional payment methods. Paddle Billing does not generate license keys, and live checkout needs a verified account and an approved domain.

FastSpring

A merchant of record for software that does not publish its rate: it is a revenue share agreed with an account executive. License keys come from generators (a list, a script or a call to your server).

Stripe Managed Payments

Stripe’s merchant of record service for digital goods: 3.5% per successful transaction plus Stripe processing fees. It supports software from supported business locations. It has no license keys, so it needs a licensing tool.

Clavem with Stripe

Clavem is not a merchant of record or a payment provider. You sell through your own Stripe account and Clavem issues the keys, enforces device limits, hosts downloads and gives buyers a device page. The price is flat by active licenses (free for 50, then $29, $79 and $199 a month), so a $12 subscription pays Clavem nothing per renewal. Stripe’s fees and your tax work remain. Clavem imports keys from Dodo Payments through its API, with instance ids preserved.

How to choose

  • Mostly cheap subscriptions with international buyers: compare Creem and Dodo on your real mix, because the fixed fee and the surcharges decide it.
  • You need the lowest fixed cost per sale and can handle tax: Stripe with a flat-price licensing tool.
  • Your country or product fails a provider’s check: that check decides the shortlist before any price does.

Questions

Who can sign up as a merchant on Dodo Payments?

Its documentation ties eligibility to the country that issued the government ID you verify with, not to where your company is registered or pays tax. For a company, the IDs of every director and beneficial owner count. Check the current list of eligible countries before you plan around it.

What products does Dodo Payments not accept?

Its merchant acceptance policy says it sells digital-first products and restricts or prohibits categories such as physical goods, illegal or age-restricted products, and categories its payment partners restrict. Read the policy for your product.

Can I move Dodo license keys to Clavem?

Yes. Clavem has a Dodo Payments importer that reads keys, buyers, status, limits, expiry dates and key instances with a read-only API key, and keeps the Dodo instance ids so apps that stored them still validate.

Sources

  1. Dodo Payments pricing (checked November 2026)
  2. Dodo Payments license keys (checked November 2026)
  3. Dodo Payments merchant acceptance policy (checked November 2026)
  4. Dodo Payments countries eligible for merchant acceptance (checked November 2026)
  5. Polar fees (checked November 2026)
  6. Creem pricing (checked November 2026)
  7. Paddle pricing (checked November 2026)
  8. Paddle Classic and Paddle Billing feature comparison (checked November 2026)
  9. FastSpring pricing (checked November 2026)
  10. Stripe Managed Payments (checked November 2026)