Why people look for an alternative
Payhip is a store for digital products with no setup effort, and its structure is easy to read. As of November 2026:
- Plans. Free Forever is $0 and takes 5% of each sale. Plus is $29 a month with a 2% fee. Pro is $99 a month with no Payhip fee. Features, products and revenue are the same on every plan.
- Processor fees on top. Payhip’s own billing page says PayPal and Stripe still charge their standard fees.
- License keys are a code and a counter. Keys can be generated for each sale or uploaded from your own list (up to 10,000 at a time, up to 100 characters each). Your app verifies a key with
GET https://payhip.com/api/v2/license/verifyand aproduct-secret-keyheader. The response hasenabled,buyer_email,usesand the date, and an empty response means verification failed. You raise or loweruseswith a separate call, and Payhip disables a key automatically when the order is refunded. - A secret in your app. Payhip warns that if the request comes from a publicly accessible or easily decompiled app, you must protect the product secret key, and offers an alternative integration on request.
- A narrow public API. The public API supports coupons and license keys at present, so other automation goes through webhooks.
None of this is a defect for a plugin or template that needs a simple check. It is a reason to compare if your app needs seats, device names or a signed offline answer.
What to check before you switch
- Your actual fee. Add the processor fee to Payhip’s percentage. On the Free plan the total is the 5% plus whatever PayPal or Stripe charges.
- Tax. Payhip handles EU and UK VAT by default and US sales tax from 1 July 2026 as a marketplace facilitator. A merchant of record also covers other jurisdictions; ask for the list.
- How your app checks a key. Your app sends a secret key header today. Another service changes the request, so budget for an app update.
- Existing keys. Keys you generated live in Payhip. Export them with their buyer emails and check that the new service can import them. Customers should not need new keys.
- Store features you use. Payhip is also a storefront, with courses and memberships. A licensing tool replaces only the key part.
A break-even for Payhip’s own plans
The plan fee against the saving per sale, before processor fees:
| Move | Extra monthly fee | Fee saved per dollar sold | Break-even sales a month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free to Plus | $29 | 3% | $967 |
| Plus to Pro | $70 | 2% | $3,500 |
| Free to Pro | $99 | 5% | $1,980 |
Below $967 a month the Free plan is cheapest, which is where most new stores sit. A flat-fee alternative has a similar break-even against a percentage, which the last section works out.
How an app checks a key
The same job, in the services that sell keys, as of November 2026:
| Service | Request | What comes back |
|---|---|---|
| Payhip | GET /api/v2/license/verify?license_key=... with a product-secret-key header |
enabled, uses, buyer_email; empty on failure |
| Gumroad | POST /v2/licenses/verify with product_id and license_key |
success, uses, a purchase record; 404 on failure |
| Clavem | POST /v1/licenses/validate with license_key and optional instance_id, no secret |
valid, license_key.status, activation_limit, activation_usage, a signed token |
Clavem’s request has no secret in the app, because the key is the credential and the answer is signed.
The alternatives
Gumroad
A store and merchant of record at 10% plus 50 cents on direct sales and 30% through Discover. Its license key verify call returns a uses count that increments on every call unless you pass increment_uses_count=false, and enforcement is up to you.
Polar
An open-source merchant of record. Starter is 5% plus 50 cents, with $20, $100 and $400 monthly plans at lower rates. Its license key benefit supports activation limits, expiry and usage quotas, and customers can deactivate their own instances.
Creem
A merchant of record at 3.9% plus 40 cents with license keys, activation limits and an activate, validate and deactivate API. No monthly fee.
Dodo Payments
A merchant of record at 4% plus 40 cents with license keys that carry an activation limit, expiry and an activation message. Surcharges apply for international payments, subscriptions and PayPal.
Clavem with Stripe
You sell through Stripe, and Clavem issues the keys, records each device, enforces the limit and gives buyers a page to remove devices. The flat monthly price (free for 50 active licenses, then $29, $79 and $199) replaces the percentage. Compare with Payhip Free: on $1,000 a month of sales Payhip takes about $50 plus processor fees, and Clavem’s Indie plan is $29 plus Stripe’s fees, and the tax work is yours. At $500 a month Payhip’s cost is lower. It imports keys from a CSV.
How to choose
- Small volume and a simple key check: Payhip Free is hard to beat, and its keys do the job.
- You need seats, device names or offline verification: a service with instances (Polar, Creem, Dodo or Clavem).
- Sales are above roughly $1,000 a month and you can handle tax: a flat price starts to win against a percentage.
Questions
How much does Payhip cost?
As of November 2026 the Free Forever plan is $0 a month with a 5% fee on each sale, Plus is $29 a month with 2%, and Pro is $99 a month with no Payhip fee. All plans have the same features, and PayPal or Stripe processing fees are charged on top.
Does Payhip handle sales tax?
Its help center says it handles digital EU and UK VAT by default, which you can switch off, and that from 1 July 2026 it handles US sales tax as a marketplace facilitator. It does not describe itself as a merchant of record for every tax.
Does Payhip support device activation limits?
Its license key system has a verify call and a usage counter you raise and lower with API calls. It has no device records, so a seat limit and a page for buyers to remove a device are your work.
Sources
- Payhip billing and upgrading (checked November 2026)
- Payhip software license keys (checked November 2026)
- Payhip public API (checked November 2026)
- Payhip US sales tax (checked November 2026)
- Payhip digital EU and UK VAT (checked November 2026)
- Gumroad pricing (checked November 2026)
- Gumroad help center, license keys (checked November 2026)
- Polar fees (checked November 2026)
- Polar license keys (checked November 2026)
- Creem pricing (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments pricing (checked November 2026)