Why people look for an alternative
Two documented reasons come up for software sellers.
The fee. Gumroad’s pricing page lists 10% plus $0.50 for direct sales and 30% for sales that arrive through Discover, its marketplace. There is no monthly charge. Since 1 January 2025 Gumroad is the merchant of record, so it also collects and remits sales tax. That is real work removed, but it is paid for on every sale.
The license key model. Gumroad’s help center describes license keys as a way to verify a purchase from your app, and says enforcement “is completely up to the creator”. The verify call is POST https://api.gumroad.com/v2/licenses/verify with product_id and license_key. Three details matter for an app that checks on every launch:
- The
usescounter goes up on every verify call unless you sendincrement_uses_count=false. If the count drifts, you correct it by hand from the Sales dashboard. - For a membership, the key stays enabled after the membership ends. The response carries
subscription_ended_at,subscription_cancelled_atandsubscription_failed_at, and your app has to read them. - The response is a purchase record with a
usesnumber. It has no device records, so a seat limit and a “remove this laptop” page are yours to build.
What to check before you switch
- Your fee at your price. The table below uses a $29 sale. Redo it with your real price, because the fixed part weighs more on cheap products.
- Whether Discover sends you sales. If a share of your buyers come from Discover, no alternative below has an equivalent marketplace.
- Who handles tax. Gumroad does today. Merchants of record (Polar, Creem, Dodo, Paddle) do too. Payhip handles EU and UK VAT by default and US sales tax as a marketplace facilitator. Stripe on its own does not.
- What your app calls. Moving off Gumroad changes the verify request, so budget an app update. Shipped versions keep calling Gumroad until users update.
- Whether keys can come with you. Work out how to export them (the Gumroad migration guide covers it) and ask the new service if it imports them. Existing buyers should not need a new key.
- Recurring revenue. Memberships and saved cards usually cannot be moved by an export. Ask each service how existing subscribers re-subscribe.
The alternatives
Payhip
A store for digital products with three plans that share the same features. The Free plan takes 5% per sale, Plus is $29 a month with 2%, and Pro is $99 a month with no Payhip fee. PayPal or Stripe processing fees are charged on top. Payhip handles EU and UK VAT by default and says it handles US sales tax from 1 July 2026 as a marketplace facilitator. License keys can be generated per sale or uploaded (up to 10,000 at a time), and the v2 verify endpoint uses a product secret key. Like Gumroad, usage counting is left to you.
Polar
A merchant of record that is open source. The Starter plan is 5% plus 50 cents and has no monthly fee; $20, $100 and $400 monthly plans lower the rate to between 3.4% and 3.8%. International cards add 1.5%. Polar’s fee examples apply the percentage to the total including VAT. Its license key benefit supports activation limits, expiry and usage quotas.
Creem
A merchant of record at 3.9% plus 40 cents, with no monthly or setup fee and no extra international card fee. License keys have activation limits and an activate, validate and deactivate API. Its checkout does not take PayPal.
Dodo Payments
A merchant of record at 4% plus 40 cents on US card payments, with listed additions: 1.5% for international payments, 0.5% for subscriptions, 3% for PayPal and buy-now-pay-later. Refunds cost $1 and disputes $30. License keys come with an activation limit and expiry. Merchant eligibility depends on the country that issued your identity documents, not where your company is registered.
Paddle
A merchant of record at 5% plus 50 cents, all-in, with no monthly fee. In Paddle Billing, Paddle does not generate license keys, so you pair it with a licensing service. Live checkout needs a verified account and an approved domain.
Clavem with Stripe
Clavem is not a payment provider. You sell through your own Stripe account and Clavem issues the keys, enforces device limits, hosts downloads and gives buyers a device page. It takes nothing from a sale: pricing is flat, from free for 50 active licenses to $199 a month. Tax is yours unless you use Stripe Managed Payments. It imports a CSV of existing keys, so a Gumroad export can come along. It has no equivalent of Discover.
Comparison on a $29 sale
Fee is the vendor’s headline rate applied to $29, before currency, international and tax effects.
| Option | Fee on $29 | Monthly fee | Tax handled by | License keys | Seat limits built in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gumroad, direct | $3.40 | $0 | Gumroad | Yes | No, a uses counter |
| Gumroad, via Discover | $8.70 | $0 | Gumroad | Yes | No, a uses counter |
| Payhip Free | $1.45 plus processor | $0 | EU and UK VAT by default, US as facilitator | Yes | No, a uses counter |
| Polar Starter | $1.95 | $0 | Polar | Yes | Yes |
| Creem | $1.53 | $0 | Creem | Yes | Yes |
| Dodo Payments | $1.56 | $0 | Dodo | Yes | Yes |
| Paddle | $1.95 | $0 | Paddle | No | Not applicable |
| Clavem with Stripe | $0 from Clavem, plus Stripe | $0 to $199 | You, or Managed Payments | Yes | Yes, with a device page |
On 100 sales of $29 a month, Gumroad’s direct fee is $340 and Creem’s is $153. The gap is the price of the merchant of record service plus Gumroad’s marketplace, and it grows with volume. Paddle, Creem, Dodo and Polar are also merchants of record, so the saving does not come from handing tax back to you.
How to choose
- If you want the same tax handling and a lower fee, compare Creem, Dodo and Polar on country eligibility and the surcharges that apply to your buyers.
- If you sell mostly to a few big markets and are comfortable with tax, Stripe plus a licensing service moves the cost from a percentage to a flat monthly price.
- If your app needs device limits and offline checks rather than a uses counter, choose a service whose key model has instances.
Questions
Is Gumroad a merchant of record?
Yes. Gumroad's pricing page says it has been the merchant of record since 1 January 2025 and handles sales tax collection and remittance in the regions where it has obligations.
Does Gumroad limit how many devices use a license key?
Not itself. Its help article says enforcement is up to the creator. The verify call returns a uses count that goes up on every call unless you pass increment_uses_count=false, and you decide what count is too high.
Can I keep my existing Gumroad license keys if I move?
Only if the new service can import them. Clavem imports a CSV of keys with their email, expiry and devices, and the Gumroad migration guide shows how to build that file. Your app also has to change, because Gumroad's verify call is not shaped like the Lemon Squeezy License API.
Sources
- Gumroad pricing (checked November 2026)
- Gumroad help center, license keys (checked November 2026)
- Payhip billing and upgrading (checked November 2026)
- Payhip software license keys (checked November 2026)
- Payhip US sales tax (checked November 2026)
- Payhip digital EU and UK VAT (checked November 2026)
- Polar fees (checked November 2026)
- Polar license keys (checked November 2026)
- Creem pricing (checked November 2026)
- Creem license keys (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments pricing (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments license keys (checked November 2026)
- Paddle pricing (checked November 2026)