Why people are looking
This is not a pricing complaint. Lemon Squeezy’s own migration guide says it is winding down. As of November 2026 the published dates are:
| Date | What happens |
|---|---|
| 16 November 2026 | No new users or store sign-ups |
| 2 December 2026 | Migration tooling for Managed Payments opens, for eligible stores |
| Mid-January 2027 | Latest start date Lemon Squeezy recommends |
| 31 March 2027 | Processing stops, including subscription renewals |
The guide says the full move, including notifying customers and cleaning up subscriptions, can take up to 8 weeks, and the FAQ says the deadline will not be extended. It recommends Stripe Managed Payments, Stripe’s merchant of record service for digital goods. The same guide lists what that destination does not include: storefronts, affiliates, PayPal, and “digital fulfillment”, meaning files, license keys and download links. Lemon Squeezy checkout links, overlays and webhook endpoints do not redirect on their own, so every place your site or app points at Lemon Squeezy needs a change.
What to check before you switch
- Can the destination sell your product? Managed Payments supports software and other digital goods in supported business locations. It does not support physical goods or professional services such as consulting. Check the eligibility page for your country before you plan around it.
- Where do license keys live after the move? If your app stores a key on the customer’s machine, handing out new keys is not an option. Ask each candidate whether it keeps existing key strings, limits, expiry dates and activations.
- Which subscriptions can move? Lemon Squeezy says only card subscriptions can move to another provider. PayPal subscriptions cannot be migrated as PayPal subscriptions, so those customers must subscribe again with a supported method. Customers with India-issued cards must reauthorise or add a new payment method.
- What changes in your product catalogue? Lemon Squeezy says Stripe has no variants, so each variant becomes its own product, descriptions over 500 characters are shortened, and only the first eight images are copied.
- Who is responsible for tax? A merchant of record sells to the buyer and handles tax. If you move to a provider that is not one, Lemon Squeezy’s guide notes that tax compliance in every applicable jurisdiction becomes your job. General information only: talk to an accountant.
- What does the shipped app call? Installed copies of your app keep calling
api.lemonsqueezy.comuntil they update. Whether that API keeps answering after March 2027 is not documented, so plan an app update.
The alternatives
Stripe Managed Payments
Lemon Squeezy’s recommended destination. Stripe’s page says it charges 3.5% per successful transaction on top of standard Stripe processing fees. Lemon Squeezy’s guide adds a promotional rate of 1.5% through 1 December 2027 for merchants who migrate. Stripe handles global indirect tax, fraud and disputes. It works with Stripe Checkout and Payment Links, and it does not deliver keys or files. The Lemon Squeezy Migration Hub copies products and customers and migrates eligible subscriptions automatically.
Dodo Payments
A merchant of record with license keys built in, priced at 4% plus 40 cents per transaction, with listed surcharges for international cards, subscriptions and PayPal. Dodo documents a dodo-migrate lemonsqueezy CLI that moves products, customers, discount codes and license keys, including key strings, activation limits and expiry dates. Activations do not carry over, so customers must activate again on each device. The CLI does not move subscriptions; Dodo documents a separate route for those.
Creem
A merchant of record at 3.9% plus 40 cents, no monthly fee, with license keys and file delivery included. Its migration guide says products, prices, discount codes, customers and checkout links move, and that active subscriptions, saved cards and existing license keys do not move yet. Subscribers check out once on Creem, timed near their Lemon Squeezy renewal. Creem’s checkout does not take PayPal.
Polar
A merchant of record that is open source, with a license key benefit that supports activation limits and expiry. The Starter plan is 5% plus 50 cents, with lower rates on $20, $100 and $400 monthly plans. Polar’s guide for Lemon Squeezy merchants says it is talking to Lemon Squeezy about taking over subscriptions without asking for cards again and is looking into importing existing keys unchanged. It suggests waiting before you choose a destination in Lemon Squeezy’s form. Sales to new customers can move now.
Paddle
A merchant of record at 5% plus 50 cents with no monthly fee, for SaaS and apps. In Paddle Billing, Paddle does not generate license keys: its feature comparison says Paddle-led fulfillment, including license key generation, has been deprecated. Live checkout needs a verified account and an approved domain. Pick Paddle if you want its tax handling and will connect a separate licensing service.
FastSpring
A merchant of record for software and digital goods. Pricing is a revenue share that FastSpring does not publish; its pricing page says to talk to an account executive, and that there is no minimum transaction volume. License keys come from fulfillment generators: a pre-defined list, a script, or a call to your own server.
Clavem (with Stripe)
Clavem is not a payment provider and not a merchant of record. It is the license, download and update layer for software sold through your own Stripe account. Its License API uses the same paths and fields as Lemon Squeezy’s, so an app changes one hostname, and it imports Lemon Squeezy keys and devices through the API or a CSV. Pricing is flat: free for 50 active licenses, then $29, $79 and $199 a month, with no cut of sales. Tax stays with you unless you use Managed Payments, which Clavem’s Stripe docs say to test with one purchase first.
Comparison
| Option | Merchant of record | Headline fee | License keys | Existing keys | Existing subscriptions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe Managed Payments | Yes | 3.5% plus Stripe fees | No | Use a licensing app | Card subscriptions via Migration Hub |
| Dodo Payments | Yes | 4% + 40 cents | Built in | CLI moves keys, not activations | Separate documented route |
| Creem | Yes | 3.9% + 40 cents | Built in | Not yet | Subscribers check out once |
| Polar | Yes | 5% + 50 cents, lower on paid plans | Built in | Being looked into | In talks with Lemon Squeezy |
| Paddle | Yes | 5% + 50 cents | No (Paddle Billing) | Use a licensing service | Ask Paddle |
| FastSpring | Yes | Not published | Generators | Ask FastSpring | Ask FastSpring |
| Clavem with Stripe | No | Flat plan, plus Stripe | Built in | Imported with devices | Subscribers need a Stripe subscription |
Fees are headline rates from each vendor’s page and do not include every surcharge. Read the full tables before you compare totals.
How to choose
- If you want tax handled and your app needs keys, take a merchant of record that has them (Dodo, Creem, Polar) or Managed Payments plus a licensing app.
- If you have thousands of shipped keys, test the key migration on one product before you commit. Moving keys is the step that cannot be redone by emailing customers.
- If you already sell through Stripe and handle tax yourself, a licensing layer such as Clavem is the smaller change.
Questions
Can the 31 March 2027 deadline be extended?
Lemon Squeezy says no. Its migration FAQ states that it will not be able to extend the date, and recommends starting no later than mid-January 2027.
Will my customers keep their license keys if I move to Stripe Managed Payments?
Not by itself. Lemon Squeezy's documentation says Managed Payments does not deliver license keys, files or download links, and that customers may lose access after 31 March 2027 unless you migrate historical orders to a fulfillment solution.
Which Lemon Squeezy alternatives can import my existing keys?
As of November 2026, Dodo Payments documents a CLI that migrates Lemon Squeezy license keys without activations. Creem lists existing keys as not moved yet, and Polar says it is looking into it. Clavem imports keys and devices through the Lemon Squeezy API or a CSV.
Sources
- Lemon Squeezy migration guide (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy wind-down FAQ (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy digital fulfillment page (checked November 2026)
- Stripe Managed Payments eligibility (checked November 2026)
- Stripe Managed Payments overview and fee (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments migration docs (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments pricing (checked November 2026)
- Creem migration guide for Lemon Squeezy (checked November 2026)
- Creem pricing (checked November 2026)
- Polar guide for Lemon Squeezy merchants (checked November 2026)
- Polar fees (checked November 2026)
- Paddle pricing (checked November 2026)
- Paddle Classic and Paddle Billing feature comparison (checked November 2026)
- FastSpring pricing (checked November 2026)
- FastSpring license key fulfillments (checked November 2026)