Why people look for an alternative
Polar’s fee page is detailed, which makes the reasons easy to state. As of November 2026:
- Plans. Starter is free and charges 5% plus 50 cents per transaction. Pro is $20 a month at 3.8% plus 40 cents, Growth is $100 at 3.6% plus 35 cents, and Scale is $400 at 3.4% plus 30 cents. Polar’s own break-even against Starter is about $1,379 a month in sales for Pro, $5,634 for Growth and $19,048 for Scale.
- The change on 27 May 2026. Organizations created before that date stay on an Early Member rate of 4% plus 40 cents, plus 0.5% on subscription payments, for as long as they stay on it. Upgrading to a paid plan retires it, and downgrading afterwards lands on Starter’s 5% plus 50 cents. New organizations start on Starter.
- Additions. International cards add 1.5%. Payouts use Stripe Connect Express and are passed through at cost: $2 a month for an active payout account and 0.25% plus $0.25 per payout. Currency conversion for cross-border payouts costs between 0.25% in the EU and 1% elsewhere.
- The base is the total. Polar’s worked example is a $30 purchase from Sweden with 25% VAT. The transaction is $37.50, and the percentage applies to that. On Starter the fee is $2.94 including the international card surcharge, which is 9.8% of the $30 product price.
None of this is hidden. It is a merchant of record that publishes its rates, which is rare. The question is whether another structure suits your buyers and your volume.
What to check before you switch
- Where your buyers are. International card surcharges matter most when most buyers are outside the United States. Check each provider’s surcharge list against your sales by country.
- The base of the percentage. Ask whether the percentage applies to the price or to price plus tax. On a 25% VAT sale the percentage part of the fee is a quarter larger when it applies to the total.
- Subscriptions. Early Member adds 0.5% on subscription payments. Others list their own subscription surcharges.
- Payout path. Polar pays out through Stripe Connect Express. Another provider may pay by different rails, with different fees and countries.
- Existing keys. If you have sold keys through Polar, the activation limits and expiry you set live in its license key benefit. Export them first and ask the new provider about import.
- Eligibility. Polar’s acceptable use policy excludes physical goods and human services. Check the same for the next provider.
The alternatives
Paddle
A merchant of record at 5% plus 50 cents, described as all-inclusive with no monthly fee and no extra cost for managing payments or additional payment methods. Paddle Billing does not generate license keys, so you attach a licensing service.
Dodo Payments
A merchant of record at 4% plus 40 cents on US card payments. Its table adds 1.5% for international payments, 0.5% for subscriptions, 3% for PayPal and buy-now-pay-later, $1 per refund and $30 per dispute. License keys are included with an activation limit and expiry. It documents a migration CLI that reads Polar data, including license keys.
Creem
A merchant of record at 3.9% plus 40 cents, no monthly fee and no international card fees, with license keys and file delivery. No PayPal at checkout.
FastSpring
A merchant of record for software that does not publish its rate: you agree a revenue share with an account executive, and there is no minimum volume. License keys come from generators: a list, a script, or a call to your server.
Stripe Managed Payments
3.5% per successful transaction plus Stripe’s processing fees, with Stripe handling global indirect tax, fraud and disputes for digital goods. It has no license keys.
Clavem with Stripe
Not a merchant of record and not a payment provider. You sell through Stripe and Clavem issues the keys, enforces device limits and hosts downloads. The price is flat by active licenses (free for 50, then $29, $79 and $199 a month) and does not grow with sales or with international buyers. Tax is yours unless you use Managed Payments. It imports keys from a CSV, so keys exported from Polar’s license key benefit can come along; Polar’s API has an endpoint to list license keys.
Fees stacked on one sale
The same $30 sale to a buyer in Sweden, from each provider’s published list, where the base is stated. Dodo’s, Creem’s and Paddle’s pages do not say whether the percentage applies to the VAT-inclusive total, so the table uses the $30 price for them and the $37.50 total for Polar, as Polar states.
| Provider | Rate used | Fee |
|---|---|---|
| Polar Starter | 5% + 50 cents + 1.5% on $37.50 | $2.94 |
| Polar Pro | 3.8% + 40 cents + 1.5% on $37.50 | $2.39 |
| Dodo Payments | 4% + 40 cents + 1.5% on $30 | $2.05 |
| Creem | 3.9% + 40 cents on $30 | $1.57 |
| Paddle | 5% + 50 cents on $30 | $2.00 |
Read the Dodo, Creem and Paddle rows as estimates until you have asked what base they use. The arithmetic is the point: the surcharges and the base move the result more than the headline rate.
How to choose
- Keep Polar if your buyers are mostly in the United States and you value the open-source platform and built-in keys.
- Compare Creem and Dodo if international card fees are your largest cost, and ask each about the base.
- Use Stripe plus a flat-price licensing tool if your volume is high enough that a percentage costs more than the work of handling tax.
Questions
Did Polar's pricing change?
Yes. Polar's fee page says organizations created before 27 May 2026 stay on the Early Member rate of 4% plus 40 cents, with a 0.5% subscription fee, and organizations created on or after that date start on Starter at 5% plus 50 cents. Paid plans at $20, $100 and $400 a month lower the rate.
Does Polar charge on the price or on the total with tax?
Its fee example applies the percentage to the total transaction value including VAT. A $30 purchase from Sweden with 25% VAT is a $37.50 transaction on its page.
Can Polar import my Lemon Squeezy license keys?
As of November 2026 Polar's guide says it is looking into a way to bring existing Lemon Squeezy keys over unchanged. For new sales, its license key benefit issues keys automatically.
Sources
- Polar fees (checked November 2026)
- Polar pricing resource page (checked November 2026)
- Polar license keys (checked November 2026)
- Polar guide for Lemon Squeezy merchants (checked November 2026)
- Polar supported countries (checked November 2026)
- Paddle pricing (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments pricing (checked November 2026)
- Creem pricing (checked November 2026)
- FastSpring pricing (checked November 2026)
- Stripe Managed Payments (checked November 2026)