Side by side
Polar facts are as of November 2026, from its pricing page and documentation.
| Clavem | Polar (as of November 2026) | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free for 50 active licenses; $29, $79 or $199 a month | Starter free; Pro $20, Growth $100, Scale $400 a month, each lowering the per-sale rate |
| Fees on 100 sales of $49 | $29 plan, plus Stripe’s fee: about $201 | Starter $295; Pro $246.20; Growth $311.40 |
| Merchant of record | No | Yes, including tax compliance, fraud and dispute handling |
| License keys | Created when Stripe confirms a payment | A benefit attached to a product: prefix, expiry, revoke on cancellation |
| Device limits | Per license; buyer device page | Activation limits; customers deactivate instances in their portal |
| Offline checks | Signed sgt1 token |
Not published |
| Downloads | Releases, order page, update endpoint | File downloads benefit: up to 10 GB per file, signed personal URLs, SHA-256 checksums |
| API | Lemon Squeezy-shaped License API plus management API | REST API, customer-portal endpoints for activate and validate, SDKs |
| Migration path | Import file; Lemon Squeezy and Dodo importers | Export through Polar’s API or CLI, then import the file |
Fees on 100 sales of $49
On $4,900 of US card sales:
- Polar Starter, 5% plus 50 cents: $245 plus $50, $295.
- Polar Pro, $20 plus 3.8% plus 40 cents: $20 plus $186.20 plus $40, $246.20.
- Polar Growth, $100 plus 3.6% plus 35 cents: $311.40.
- Polar Early Member, 4% plus 40 cents, for organizations created before 27 May 2026: $236, or $260.50 if the sales are subscription payments, which add 0.5%.
- Clavem Indie plus Stripe’s standard 2.9% plus 30 cents (as of November 2026): $29 plus $172.10, $201.10.
Polar’s page says Pro pays off against Starter above about $1,379 of monthly sales. Add 1.5% on cards issued outside the US, and Stripe’s payout fees, which Polar passes through without markup: $2 a month for active payouts, plus 0.25% and 25 cents per payout, and 0.25% to 1% for currency conversion.
At $49 a sale, Polar’s Starter plan costs $2.95 per sale and Clavem Indie with Stripe costs $1.721 per sale plus the $29 plan, so Clavem is cheaper from about 24 sales a month. Against Polar Pro, at $2.262 per sale plus $20, the crossover is about 17 sales. Both figures leave out tax handling, which is what Polar’s rate pays for.
The comparison is between different services. Polar’s rate covers tax collection and remittance as the merchant of record. With Clavem you keep Stripe as the system for money, tax and invoices and carry that duty yourself, or add Stripe Managed Payments at 3.5% on top of payment fees.
What Polar’s keys do
Polar’s documentation lists these license key features: brandable prefixes, expiry after a number of days, months or years for one-time purchases, automatic revocation when a subscription ends, activation limits, custom validation conditions, usage quotas per key, and rotation by the customer or by you. For a subscription the key has no expires_at, and your app should read the key’s status instead.
The activate, validate and deactivate calls are customer-portal endpoints that take your organization id. They are not shaped like the Lemon Squeezy License API, so moving an app between Polar and Clavem is a code change in both directions.
What the buyer sees
On Polar, a customer finds their license key under their purchases page and can view and copy it, see its expiry and remaining usage, deactivate activations if you enabled them, and rotate the key if it leaks. Rotation generates a new key string on the same record and the old string stops validating at once, while status, usage, limits, expiry and activations are kept.
On Clavem, a buyer gets a private order page with the key, the downloads and your activation instructions, and a device page where they free a seat without writing to you. Clavem’s documentation does not describe key rotation; if a key leaks you would disable the license and create a new one through the management API. Which of the two suits your support load depends on how often your customers share keys by mistake.
When Polar is the better choice
- You want a merchant of record. Polar sells to the buyer and handles tax, so your own tax duties shrink.
- Your sales are small. A percentage of a small amount is less than a monthly plan.
- You want usage quotas per key, or other benefits such as GitHub or Discord access in the same checkout.
- You value an open-source platform you can read. Polar’s documentation describes it as an open-source merchant of record.
- You do not already have a Stripe account you want to keep using.
When Clavem is the better choice
- You already sell through your own Stripe account, and want customers, payouts and invoices to stay there.
- Sales are high enough that a flat plan costs less than a percentage. At $20,000 a month, Polar’s Scale plan is $400 plus 3.4%, which is $1,080 before the per-sale cents. Clavem Studio is $79 plus Stripe’s 2.9%, which is $659 before its per-sale cents, and you handle tax yourself.
- You want a signed token your app can verify without a connection.
- Your app calls the Lemon Squeezy License API and you want to change only the hostname.
Moving from Polar to Clavem
Polar’s API exposes license keys, and its CLI has a license_keys command. Export keys with buyer, limit, expiry and activations into a file and import it; see importing licenses. New sales need Stripe Checkout or Payment Links connected to Clavem, and you take over tax. More: moving from Polar.
Questions
What does Polar charge?
As of November 2026 Polar's free Starter plan charges 5% plus 50 cents per transaction. Pro is $20 a month at 3.8% plus 40 cents, Growth $100 at 3.6% plus 35 cents, and Scale $400 at 3.4% plus 30 cents. Cards issued outside the US add 1.5%. Organizations created before 27 May 2026 can stay on an Early Member rate.
Does Polar offer license keys with device limits?
Yes. Its license key benefit supports activation limits for devices, expiry for one-time purchases, automatic revocation when a subscription ends, usage quotas, and key rotation by the customer. Its documentation does not describe offline signed tokens.
Can I move existing Lemon Squeezy keys to Polar?
Polar's own Lemon Squeezy page says it is looking into a way to bring existing keys over unchanged, and for now issues new keys for new sales. Clavem has an importer for Lemon Squeezy keys.