Clavem

Polar vs Lemon Squeezy: what a Lemon Squeezy seller gets and loses by moving to Polar

Polar and Lemon Squeezy both charge a base of 5% plus 50 cents as merchants of record, and both issue license keys with activation limits and host files. Polar adds cheaper paid tiers and is open source; it has no PayPal, and it cannot yet bring Lemon Squeezy's existing license keys across. Lemon Squeezy stops processing on 31 March 2027.

Side by side

Facts are as of November 2026, from each company’s own pages.

Polar Lemon Squeezy
Price Starter free; Pro $20, Growth $100, Scale $400 a month No monthly fee
Base rate 5% plus 50 cents on Starter; 3.8% plus 40, 3.6% plus 35, 3.4% plus 30 cents on paid plans 5% plus 50 cents
Extras +1.5% for non-US cards; payout fees passed through from Stripe +1.5% non-US, +1.5% PayPal, +0.5% subscriptions, payout fees
Fees on 100 sales of $49 Starter $295; Pro $246.20; Growth $311.40 $295; $319.50 as subscriptions
Merchant of record Yes Yes
License keys A benefit on a product: prefix, expiry, revoke on cancellation, usage quota Generated per customer, with a length and an activation limit
Device limits Activation limits; customers deactivate in their portal Activation limit and key instances
Offline checks Not published Not published
Downloads File downloads: up to 10 GB per file, signed personal URLs Hosts files, with file versions
API REST API with customer-portal endpoints, SDKs and a CLI REST API plus a separate License API
Status Open; the page also lists an Early Member rate for organizations created before 27 May 2026 Closed to new sign-ups; stops 31 March 2027
Migration path Customer and subscription takeover still under discussion; keys not yet portable Tooling to Stripe Managed Payments; other providers via an intake form

Fees on 100 sales of $49

As of November 2026, at the base rate the two are identical: $245 plus $50, $295 on $4,900 of US card sales. The differences appear around it.

  • Polar Pro costs $20 plus 3.8% ($186.20) plus 40 cents a sale ($40): $246.20. Polar’s page puts the break-even against Starter at about $1,379 of monthly sales for Pro, $5,634 for Growth and $19,048 for Scale.
  • Polar charges no separate subscription fee on Starter, Pro, Growth or Scale. Lemon Squeezy adds 0.5% on subscription payments.
  • Both add 1.5% on non-US cards. Lemon Squeezy adds another 1.5% for PayPal. Polar does not offer PayPal yet.
  • Polar’s Early Member rate of 4% plus 40 cents applies to organizations created before 27 May 2026, plus 0.5% on subscription payments. New organizations start on Starter.
  • Payouts: Polar passes on Stripe’s payout fees without markup. Lemon Squeezy lists its own: 1% per payout to a bank account outside the US through Stripe, and a fee on PayPal payouts.

What a Lemon Squeezy seller should know before moving

Polar’s page on moving from Lemon Squeezy is direct about what is not ready.

Subscriptions and customers. Polar says it is in conversation with Lemon Squeezy about taking over active subscriptions and customers without asking anyone to re-enter card details, and recommends waiting before picking a destination in Lemon Squeezy’s migration form. In the meantime you can send new sales to Polar and let existing customers keep renewing on Lemon Squeezy.

License keys. Many desktop apps and plugins store a key on the customer’s device, so reissuing is not an option. Polar says it is looking into bringing existing keys over unchanged. Until that exists, a Polar seller who has shipped apps against Lemon Squeezy keys has two choices: keep validating the old keys against a service you control, or issue new keys and ask customers to enter them.

Payment methods. PayPal subscriptions cannot be migrated to any provider, according to Lemon Squeezy’s documentation, so those customers must subscribe again. India-issued cards need a new payment method if you move to Polar. Cash App Pay and Link can only move to Stripe Managed Payments.

A sensible order of operations

Lemon Squeezy’s migration page recommends starting by mid-January 2027 for stores moving to Managed Payments, and Polar’s page suggests holding off on picking a destination in Lemon Squeezy’s form until its customer takeover is settled. Both are cautious, so a Lemon Squeezy seller evaluating Polar can:

  1. Open a Polar account and test a license key product in its sandbox.
  2. Send new sales to Polar when you are ready, while existing customers keep renewing on Lemon Squeezy.
  3. Export orders, customers and subscriptions from Lemon Squeezy before 31 March 2027, as its documentation advises.
  4. Decide how installed apps will validate old keys, since Polar cannot take them over yet.
  5. Ship an app update before the deadline that calls wherever the keys will live.

Polar’s documentation lists a sandbox environment under its API section.

When Polar is the better choice

  • You want a merchant of record that is accepting new sellers, with published tier pricing.
  • Your volume is rising and the paid plans lower the per-sale rate.
  • You want usage quotas per key, or file downloads and other benefits in one purchase.
  • You prefer an open-source platform.
  • Your customers pay by card, Apple Pay or Google Pay, not PayPal.

When Lemon Squeezy is the better choice

For an existing store, staying until you have moved is reasonable: it works until 31 March 2027, its PayPal support is complete, and its keys keep working for your current customers. For a new project it is not available.

Where Clavem fits

Clavem is not a merchant of record; it supplies license keys, device seats and downloads on your own Stripe account, and imports existing Lemon Squeezy keys by API key or CSV, which keeps them valid. A seller who moves payments to Polar could host the old keys on Clavem, so installed apps keep validating after a hostname change, while new sales get Polar’s keys. The app would then call two services. See Clavem and Polar and moving from Lemon Squeezy.

Questions

Can I move my Lemon Squeezy license keys to Polar?

Not yet, according to Polar. Its Lemon Squeezy page says it is looking into a way to bring existing keys over unchanged. For now, Polar's license key benefit issues new keys for new sales, so installed apps still hold Lemon Squeezy keys.

Does Polar support PayPal?

Not yet. Polar's Lemon Squeezy page says PayPal is a gap and on its radar, without a timeline. Polar supports cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay and some local payment methods.

Is Polar cheaper than Lemon Squeezy?

On the free Starter plan the base rate is the same, 5% plus 50 cents. Polar's paid plans lower the rate to between 3.8% plus 40 cents and 3.4% plus 30 cents for $20 to $400 a month, and it adds no separate subscription fee. Both add 1.5% for cards from outside the US.

Sources

  1. Polar pricing page (checked November 2026)
  2. Polar documentation, migrating from Lemon Squeezy (checked November 2026)
  3. Polar documentation, license keys (checked November 2026)
  4. Polar documentation, file downloads (checked November 2026)
  5. Lemon Squeezy fees (checked November 2026)
  6. Lemon Squeezy migration documentation (checked November 2026)