Side by side
Facts are as of November 2026, from each company’s own pages.
| Gumroad | Lemon Squeezy | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | No monthly fee | No monthly fee |
| Base rate | 10% plus 50 cents on direct sales; 30% on Discover sales | 5% plus 50 cents on the total order value |
| Extras | None listed on the pricing page | +1.5% non-US, +1.5% PayPal, +0.5% subscriptions, payout fees |
| Fees on 100 sales of $49 | $540 | $295; $319.50 as subscriptions |
| Merchant of record | Yes, for tax collection and remittance since 1 January 2025 | Yes, including tax collection and filing |
| License keys | Enabled on a product’s content page; multi-seat option | Generated per customer with a length and activation limit |
| Device limits | A uses count that you interpret | Activation limit and key instances |
| Offline checks | Not published | Not published |
| Downloads | Product content delivered to the buyer | Hosts files, with file versions |
| API | A verify endpoint | REST API plus a License API with activate, validate and deactivate |
| Status | Operating | Closed to new sign-ups; stops 31 March 2027 |
| Migration path | Not published | Tooling to Stripe Managed Payments; keys and files do not move |
Fees on 100 sales of $49
As of November 2026, on $4,900 of direct US card sales, Gumroad takes 10% ($490) plus 50 cents a sale ($50): $540. Lemon Squeezy takes 5% ($245) plus $50: $295, or $319.50 if the sales are subscription payments. Adding 1.5% for non-US cards or PayPal raises either Lemon Squeezy figure by $73.50. The gap at this volume is about $245 a month in Lemon Squeezy’s favour.
Gumroad’s Discover rate is 30%: a new customer who finds you through the marketplace is charged at that rate instead of the 10% rate for your own link. Lemon Squeezy lists no marketplace fee, but it does list extra fees for payments recovered through abandoned-cart emails and for affiliate referrals.
How the keys differ in code
The two checks look different in your app. Lemon Squeezy’s License API activates a device once and then validates against the instance it returned:
curl https://api.lemonsqueezy.com/v1/licenses/activate \
-H "Accept: application/json" \
-d license_key=YOUR-KEY -d instance_name="Ada's MacBook"
Gumroad has one verify call that takes a product id and the key, and raises uses by one unless told not to:
curl https://api.gumroad.com/v2/licenses/verify -X POST \
-d product_id=YOUR-PRODUCT-ID -d license_key=YOUR-KEY \
-d increment_uses_count=false
On Lemon Squeezy the activation limit is enforced for you: when every seat is in use, the activate call fails with a message that the key has reached its limit. On Gumroad you decide. If your app checks on every launch and you leave the counter on, uses climbs with launches. Decide whether to turn the counter off or to count only first runs.
Gumroad’s help adds that for memberships the license API keeps showing a key as enabled until you disable it, and gives you subscription-ended, cancelled and failed timestamps to act on. Lemon Squeezy’s documentation says subscription keys are linked to the subscription lifecycle.
Payouts, tax and refunds
Gumroad’s FAQ says it pays creators by direct deposit or PayPal, depending on the country, and that since 1 January 2025 it handles sales tax collection and remittance worldwide as merchant of record. Its verify response reports refunded, disputed and chargebacked flags, so an app can refuse a key whose purchase was reversed. Lemon Squeezy pays out to a bank account or PayPal and lists payout fees: 1% per payout to a non-US bank through Stripe, a flat 50 cents per PayPal payout for US accounts, and 3% capped at $30 for PayPal accounts outside the US.
If you are leaving Lemon Squeezy for Gumroad
Neither company’s documentation describes moving existing Lemon Squeezy license keys into Gumroad, so treat it as not available. Lemon Squeezy says customers may lose access to their keys, files and links after 31 March 2027 unless historical orders move to a new fulfilment solution. On Gumroad, new sales get Gumroad keys, and your shipped apps still send the old keys to Lemon Squeezy. You would need your own service to keep answering for the old keys, or a way to import them, and your app would check two places until customers have moved. Gumroad’s verify call also needs a product id, so your app’s code changes whichever way you go.
When Gumroad is the better choice
- You want a hosted storefront with a seller profile and a marketplace that can bring new customers.
- Your keys are a courtesy and a valid-or-not answer is enough.
- You are taking new sales: Gumroad is open, and Lemon Squeezy is not.
- You want multi-seat keys sold by quantity on a single product page.
When Lemon Squeezy is the better choice
For an existing store with real device limits, Lemon Squeezy’s keys are the stronger design, and a 5% base is half Gumroad’s. It works until 31 March 2027. For a new project it is not available.
Where Clavem fits
Clavem is neither a storefront nor a merchant of record; it adds license keys, device seats and downloads to a Stripe account, and answers on the same paths and fields as Lemon Squeezy’s License API. A seller leaving either platform can import existing keys from a file, and a seller leaving Lemon Squeezy can import by API key or CSV. See Clavem and Gumroad and Clavem and Lemon Squeezy.
Questions
Which is cheaper, Gumroad or Lemon Squeezy?
Lemon Squeezy, on the base rate. As of November 2026 Gumroad lists 10% plus 50 cents on direct sales and 30% for sales through its Discover marketplace. Lemon Squeezy lists 5% plus 50 cents, plus extras for non-US transactions, PayPal and subscriptions.
Do Gumroad license keys limit devices?
Not by themselves. Gumroad's help says enforcement is up to the creator. Each verify call can increase a uses count, and you decide how many uses a key gets. Lemon Squeezy's keys have an activation limit and per-device instances.
Is Lemon Squeezy still taking new sellers?
No. It closed new store sign-ups on 16 November 2026 and stops processing transactions on 31 March 2027, according to its migration documentation.
Sources
- Gumroad pricing page (checked November 2026)
- Gumroad help center, license keys (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy fees (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy documentation, generating license keys (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy License API documentation (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy migration documentation (checked November 2026)