Side by side
Facts are as of November 2026, from each company’s own pages.
| Lemon Squeezy | Paddle | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | No monthly fee | No monthly fee; custom pricing for high volume or products under $10 |
| Base rate | 5% plus 50 cents on the total order value | 5% plus 50 cents per checkout transaction |
| Extras | +1.5% non-US, +1.5% PayPal, +0.5% subscriptions, payout fees | None listed on the pricing page |
| Fees on 100 sales of $49 | $295 for US one-time card sales; $319.50 as subscriptions | $295 |
| Merchant of record | Yes, including tax collection and filing | Yes, with tax, fraud, chargebacks and buyer support |
| License keys | Generated per customer with a length and an activation limit | Not in Paddle Billing; build your own |
| Device limits | Activation limit and key instances | Not part of Paddle Billing |
| Offline checks | Not published | Not part of Paddle Billing |
| Downloads | Hosts files, with file versions | Not in Paddle Billing; generate your own download URL |
| API | REST API plus a separate License API | Paddle Billing API, webhooks, Paddle.js |
| Status | Closed to new sign-ups; stops 31 March 2027 | Taking sign-ups: its pricing page offers Get started |
| Migration path | Tooling to Stripe Managed Payments from 2 December 2026; keys and files do not move | Says your data is yours and can be migrated; custom plan includes migration support |
Fees on 100 sales of $49
As of November 2026, on $4,900 of US card sales, both bases give 5% ($245) plus 50 cents a sale ($50), which is $295. Lemon Squeezy’s documentation lists add-ons: another 1.5% on non-US transactions, 1.5% for PayPal and 0.5% for subscription payments, so a month of subscription sales is $319.50. It also lists payout fees: 1% per payout to a bank account outside the US through Stripe, and a fee on PayPal payouts. Paddle’s pricing page lists none of these and says there are no monthly fees, migration fees or hidden extras. Read Paddle’s terms for anything that applies to your countries and payment methods.
What changes with the shutdown
Lemon Squeezy stopped new sign-ups on 16 November 2026. Its migration tooling for Managed Payments opens on 2 December 2026, and it stops processing, including renewals, on 31 March 2027. Its documentation recommends starting by mid-January 2027, and says the move can take up to eight weeks. It also says license keys and files do not migrate automatically, and that customers may lose access to them after the deadline unless you move the historical orders to a new fulfilment solution.
That is the part a seller of software should weigh against Paddle. Moving from Lemon Squeezy to Paddle changes the checkout and the tax handler, but Paddle will not hold your keys. You still need a way to issue, store and validate them.
What each does for software
Lemon Squeezy let you tick a setting to generate a license key per customer, with a length and an activation limit, linked to the subscription lifecycle for subscriptions. A License API lets an app activate, validate and deactivate. It hosted the downloads.
Paddle Billing treats fulfilment as yours. Its guide for moving from Classic to Billing lists the steps: listen for transaction.completed webhooks, generate a unique download URL, and email the customer who paid. Paddle Classic used to send downloads or license keys on its own; that is the part Billing no longer does.
If you are moving from Lemon Squeezy to Paddle
Lemon Squeezy’s migration page says that for a provider other than Managed Payments you contact the new provider about its requirements and complete Lemon Squeezy’s intake form, and that only subscriptions paid by card can be migrated to another provider. PayPal subscriptions cannot move anywhere, so those customers subscribe again. Plan around these points:
- Customer and subscription data: ask Paddle what it can import and in what format, and export your orders, customers and subscriptions from Lemon Squeezy before 31 March 2027.
- Keys and files: nothing moves. Paddle Billing will not host them, so decide where they live before you cut over.
- Your app: shipped versions call Lemon Squeezy’s License API, and none of its links or integrations redirect automatically. Ship an update that calls wherever the keys now live.
- Tax: both are merchants of record, so your tax position changes little, but check where each is registered to file for the countries you sell in.
When Lemon Squeezy is the better choice
For a store that already exists, staying put until you have moved is reasonable: it works until 31 March 2027, and its keys and files keep working for your customers in the meantime. For a new project it is not available, so this is the only case.
When Paddle is the better choice
- You want a merchant of record that is taking new sellers and is not on a shutdown clock.
- You sell subscriptions and want its checkout, billing and metrics in one place.
- You already have, or will build, key issuing and downloads separately.
- You want custom pricing and migration support at higher volume.
Where Clavem fits
Clavem is not a merchant of record and does not compete with either on tax. It supplies the key, device limit, download and order page that Lemon Squeezy bundled and Paddle Billing does not, on top of a Stripe account. It reads Stripe only, so it does not connect to Paddle’s sales without custom code. Sellers who want a merchant of record and licensing together are likelier to pair Stripe Managed Payments with Clavem; see Clavem and Lemon Squeezy and Clavem and Paddle.
Questions
Is Lemon Squeezy shutting down?
Yes. As of November 2026 Lemon Squeezy has closed new store sign-ups and says it will stop processing transactions, including subscription renewals, on 31 March 2027, with no extensions. It recommends Stripe Managed Payments as the destination.
Does Paddle provide license keys like Lemon Squeezy did?
Not in Paddle Billing. Paddle's migration guide says Paddle Classic sent downloads and license keys itself, while in Paddle Billing you build your own fulfilment from the transaction.completed webhook.
Which is cheaper, Lemon Squeezy or Paddle?
Both list 5% plus 50 cents as the base rate. Lemon Squeezy adds 1.5% for non-US transactions, 1.5% for PayPal and 0.5% for subscription payments, while Paddle's pricing page lists no extras and offers custom pricing for high volume.
Sources
- Lemon Squeezy pricing (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy fees (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy migration documentation (checked November 2026)
- Lemon Squeezy documentation, generating license keys (checked November 2026)
- Paddle pricing page (checked November 2026)
- Paddle developer docs, workflow mapping between Classic and Billing (checked November 2026)