Clavem

Paddle vs FastSpring for software sellers: published pricing against a quoted one

Paddle and FastSpring are both merchants of record for software. Paddle publishes one price, 5% plus 50 cents, and leaves license keys and downloads to you in Paddle Billing. FastSpring does not publish a rate, but its products can generate license keys and deliver files at purchase, and it connects to licensing tools for the rest.

Side by side

Facts are as of November 2026, from each company’s own pages. Where a number is not published, the table says so.

Paddle FastSpring
Price No monthly fee; custom pricing for high volume or products under $10 Revenue share; fees vary by volume; not published
Fees on 100 sales of $49 5% plus 50 cents: $295 Not published
Merchant of record Yes, with tax, fraud protection, chargebacks and buyer support Yes: it handles taxes including VAT
License keys Not in Paddle Billing; build your own A Generate a License fulfilment: list, script, remote request or a third-party format
Device limits Not part of Paddle Billing Not part of the key fulfilment; use a connected licensing tool
Offline checks Not part of Paddle Billing Not published
Downloads Not in Paddle Billing; generate your own URL A File Downloads fulfilment
API Paddle Billing API, webhooks, Paddle.js Developer tools and extensions; keys from generators
Status Taking sign-ups Taking enquiries; calculator and account executive
Migration path Says your data is yours and can be migrated Not published

Fees on 100 sales of $49

As of November 2026 Paddle’s rate gives a number: 5% of $4,900 is $245 and 50 cents a sale is $50, so $295. FastSpring’s pricing page asks for a product category, monthly sales volume, transaction count and geographic split into a calculator, and says the result is best discussed with an account executive. A comparable figure for 100 sales of $49 is not published, and this page does not guess one. Ask FastSpring for a written quote at your volume, and compare it with $295 including tax handling on both sides.

Small products matter here. Paddle’s page says that products under $10 are priced by contacting Paddle. FastSpring says it has no minimum transaction volume.

How each handles license keys

Paddle. Paddle’s guide to moving from Classic to Billing says that in Classic, fulfilment for one-time items was Paddle-led: you set up download links or license keys when creating a product, and Paddle sent them after purchase. In Billing you build your own logic: listen for transaction.completed, generate a unique download URL, and email the buyer. A seller needing keys on Paddle Billing builds the issuing and validation, or adds a licensing service.

FastSpring. A product’s fulfilments can include Generate a License. You choose a generator, from a pre-defined list you paste in, a script FastSpring runs, a remote server request that creates a custom key during the order, or a third-party format such as AquaticPrime, CocoaFob or Software Passport. The key appears on the completion page, in the receipt email and in the account portal. Tracking which devices use a key is outside that fulfilment: FastSpring’s integrations list names Quick License Manager, LimeLM, Nalpeiron, 10Duke, SoftwareKey SOLO Server and Cryptlex.

So on FastSpring a licensing tool is an add-on to the key, while on Paddle it is a build or buy decision for the whole feature.

Checkout and integration surface

Paddle describes a branded checkout you can embed in a site or app, driven by Paddle.js, with a success URL and an event callback when a checkout completes. FastSpring’s documentation lists popup, embedded, web and component checkouts, the last still in beta, plus extensions and a Zapier integration. Both let you keep the buyer on your page. The difference for a software seller is less the checkout than what happens after it: Paddle sends you a transaction.completed event and expects you to fulfil, while FastSpring can fulfil a key and a download itself.

Questions to put to each vendor

A published price is easier to compare, but both rates still leave points open. Ask each vendor for written answers:

  • What is the rate on subscription renewals, non-US cards and PayPal, and does anything extra apply to your countries?
  • When and how are you paid, in which currencies, and what fees apply to payouts?
  • Which tax forms and reports will you receive? FastSpring’s documentation has pages on W-8 and W-9 reporting, 1099-K reporting and US tax withholding for downloadable subscription software.
  • Who issues and stores license keys, and who tracks device activations?
  • How do you export customers, subscriptions and keys if you leave? Paddle says your data is yours and can be migrated. FastSpring’s pricing page does not say.

Use the answers to price a full set: the merchant-of-record rate, plus any licensing tool you add, plus your own time.

When Paddle is the better choice

  • You want to know the price before you start: one published rate.
  • You sell subscriptions or SaaS and want its checkout, billing and metrics tools.
  • You are an app or software seller starting out, with no need for a sales conversation.
  • You have, or will build, licensing and delivery separately.

When FastSpring is the better choice

  • You want keys generated and delivered at purchase from the same vendor.
  • You sell downloadable software with invoiced or quoted B2B deals, resellers or affiliates. Its site lists digital invoicing, interactive quotes and an affiliate network.
  • You already use one of the licensing tools it integrates with.
  • You want a negotiated rate and an account executive.

Where Clavem fits

Clavem is not a merchant of record and reads Stripe only, so it does not connect to either platform’s checkout without custom code. It answers a different question: if you leave a merchant of record for Stripe, what issues keys, counts devices and delivers files? That is its job, for a flat monthly price. See Clavem and Paddle and Clavem and FastSpring.

Questions

Does FastSpring publish its fees?

No. As of November 2026 FastSpring's pricing page says its pricing is based on a revenue-sharing model, that fees vary with the transaction volume you move through it, and that the right terms are discussed with an account executive. It says it has no minimum transaction volume.

Which gives license keys, Paddle or FastSpring?

FastSpring can generate keys at purchase through a Generate a License fulfilment. Paddle Billing does not. Paddle's migration guide says to build your own fulfilment from transaction.completed webhooks, though the older Paddle Classic sent keys and downloads itself.

Which is easier to start with?

Paddle publishes a single rate and a Get started button. FastSpring offers a pricing calculator and an account executive, which suits larger or more complex sellers but takes a conversation before you know the price.

Sources

  1. Paddle pricing page (checked November 2026)
  2. Paddle developer docs, workflow mapping between Classic and Billing (checked November 2026)
  3. FastSpring pricing page (checked November 2026)
  4. FastSpring developer documentation, license keys (checked November 2026)