Why people look for an alternative
Paddle is a merchant of record: it sells your software to the buyer, collects and remits tax, and pays you the rest. Its pricing page lists one rate, 5% plus 50 cents per transaction, with no monthly, migration or hidden fees. Nothing in that is a complaint. The reasons sellers compare it with others come from two documented places.
- No license keys. Paddle’s feature comparison between Classic and Billing says Paddle-led fulfillment, including product delivery and license key generation, has been deprecated. In Paddle Billing you build fulfillment from webhooks and the event stream. A desktop app that sells keys needs a licensing service or your own server.
- Going live has gates. The go-live checklist says live checkout needs a verified account and an approved domain, and tells sellers to submit domains and complete account setup early to avoid delays. Sandbox needs neither.
A third reason is a matter of rates. Several newer merchants of record list lower headline fees, and the table below puts them next to Paddle’s.
What to check before you switch
- Your fulfillment code. Your server probably listens to Paddle webhooks to create a key or grant access. Every event name and payload field in that code changes with a new provider.
- Checkout. Paddle.js overlay or inline checkout on your site, plus any checkout links in emails and docs, have to be replaced.
- Subscribers. A merchant of record holds the payment relationship. Lemon Squeezy asks sellers to file an intake form to move subscriptions to another provider, and Dodo Payments documents a card data export as a request, so treat card migration as something you ask Paddle for, not something you do from a download. Plan for subscribers who have to check out again.
- Tax. If you leave a merchant of record for plain Stripe, sales tax and VAT registration become yours. General information only: ask an accountant.
- Country and product rules. Merchants of record accept some countries and products and not others. Check eligibility before you rebuild.
- Exit terms. Paddle’s pricing FAQ says there are no lock-in periods and your data can be migrated to another provider. Ask what the export contains.
A worked example
You sell a $79 license, 200 times a month ($15,800). Headline fees on the price, as of November 2026:
| Provider | Fee per sale | Per month | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paddle | $4.45 | $890.00 | 5% + 50 cents, all-inclusive |
| Polar Starter | $4.45 | $890.00 | 5% + 50 cents |
| Polar Pro | $3.40 | $700.40 | 3.8% + 40 cents, plus $20 a month |
| Dodo Payments | $3.56 | $712.00 | 4% + 40 cents, US card |
| Creem | $3.48 | $696.20 | 3.9% + 40 cents |
| Stripe Managed Payments | $2.77 | $553.00 | 3.5%, plus Stripe’s own fees |
The Managed Payments row leaves out Stripe processing fees, which are charged on top. Polar’s examples apply the percentage to the total including VAT, and Dodo lists extra percentages for international cards and subscriptions, so buyers outside the United States cost more on the other rows too.
The alternatives
Stripe Managed Payments
Stripe’s merchant of record service for digital goods. It charges 3.5% per successful transaction on top of standard Stripe fees and handles global indirect tax, fraud and disputes. It supports software and other digital products from supported business locations, not physical goods or professional services. It does not generate license keys, so you pair it with a licensing tool.
FastSpring
A merchant of record for software with revenue-share pricing that it does not publish; you get a rate from an account executive, and there is no minimum volume. License keys come from fulfillment generators: a pre-defined list, a PHP or JavaScript script, or a request to your own server.
Polar
A merchant of record that is open source, with a license key benefit that supports activation limits and expiry. Payouts go through Stripe Connect Express, and its docs say payments are accepted globally except from countries under US sanctions.
Dodo Payments
A merchant of record at 4% plus 40 cents with license keys included. It documents a Dodo Migrate CLI for products and customers from Lemon Squeezy, Stripe, Polar and Paddle (license keys only from Lemon Squeezy and Polar), and a separate subscription migration process for saved cards from Stripe, Paddle and others. Merchant eligibility follows the country that issued your identity documents.
Creem
A merchant of record at 3.9% plus 40 cents with license keys and file delivery included. No monthly fee, no international card surcharge, and no PayPal at checkout.
Staying on Paddle and adding keys
If Paddle is fine and only the keys are missing, add a licensing service that listens to Paddle. LicenseManager lists Paddle and Stripe integrations. Keygen documents a webhook route for Stripe; with Paddle you would write the equivalent against Paddle’s events. You keep Paddle’s tax handling and your buyers keep their subscriptions.
Clavem with Stripe
Clavem reads Stripe, not Paddle, so it fits if you move payments to Stripe. It issues keys on paid checkouts, enforces device limits, hosts downloads and gives buyers a device page, for a flat monthly price from free (50 active licenses) to $199 with no cut of sales. It is not a merchant of record. With Stripe Managed Payments you can have both tax handling and Clavem’s keys; its Stripe docs say to test one purchase before relying on that.
How to choose
- Keep Paddle if you want its tax handling and only the keys are missing: attach a licensing service.
- Move to Dodo, Creem or Polar if you want a merchant of record with keys built in and a lower headline rate, and your country and product pass their checks.
- Move to Stripe with Managed Payments and a licensing tool if you want Stripe’s dashboard and are happy with a fee plus processing.
Questions
Does Paddle generate license keys?
Not in Paddle Billing. Paddle's feature comparison says Paddle-led fulfillment, including product delivery and license key generation, has been deprecated, and that you build fulfillment from webhooks and events.
Does Clavem work with Paddle?
No. Clavem has no Paddle connector. It reads Stripe. If you want to keep Paddle for payments and add keys, a service with a Paddle integration, such as LicenseManager, or your own code on Paddle webhooks, is the route.
Can I move my Paddle subscribers' saved cards to a new provider?
That is a request to Paddle and the new provider, not a file you can download. Ask both in writing what is possible before you promise customers anything.
Sources
- Paddle pricing (checked November 2026)
- Paddle Classic and Paddle Billing feature comparison (checked November 2026)
- Paddle go-live checklist (checked November 2026)
- Stripe Managed Payments (checked November 2026)
- Stripe Managed Payments eligibility (checked November 2026)
- FastSpring pricing (checked November 2026)
- FastSpring license key fulfillments (checked November 2026)
- Polar fees (checked November 2026)
- Polar supported countries (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments pricing (checked November 2026)
- Dodo Payments migration docs (checked November 2026)
- Creem pricing (checked November 2026)
- LicenseManager (checked November 2026)
- Keygen and Stripe integration page (checked November 2026)